The subscription app usually gets picked by the founder or the ops lead, after a demo and a pricing call. The email team finds out a week before the switch. That's backwards, because the app decides which data Klaviyo gets, how easy it is for a subscriber to skip instead of cancel, and how many flows need rebuilding on migration day. This Recharge vs Loop vs Skio comparison, with Stay AI added, looks at the apps from that side.
A quick warning before we start. All four apps ship features fast. What's true in this guide may be out of date in six months, so treat it as a list of what to check, and confirm every point with the vendor's current docs or a demo. We don't cover pricing at all.
What matters from the email side
When we look at a subscription app for a client, we care about four things. Billing logic and checkout matter too, but someone else is better placed to judge those.
1. Which events and properties reach Klaviyo
Every flow you build depends on this. At minimum you want events for a new subscription, an upcoming order, a failed payment, a skip and a cancellation. On the profile, you want subscription status, next order date and ideally the products and the cancellation reason. The more of that arrives, the more specific your emails can be. Our guide to subscription email marketing shows what we do with each event.
2. How flexible the customer portal is
Your order reminder email links into the portal. If skipping, swapping or changing the date takes one tap there, the email works. If the subscriber has to dig through menus, many of them will cancel instead, and no email fixes that.
3. How the cancel flow works
Most apps now show retention offers before someone confirms a cancellation. You need to know exactly what yours shows, so your Klaviyo cancellation flow doesn't repeat an offer the subscriber just declined.
4. What a migration costs you
Switching apps means every Klaviyo trigger, segment and flow filter built on the old app's data goes quiet. How much work that is depends on how many flows you run and how well the new app's data matches the old one.
Recharge vs Loop vs Skio vs Stay AI at a glance
This table reflects how the vendors generally position themselves and what we look at in each. Use it as a starting point for your own checks.
| Recharge | Loop | Skio | Stay AI | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Klaviyo integration | Yes, long established | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Known for | One of the oldest and most widely used options on Shopify | Shopify-focused setup with a strong portal and retention flows | Easy portal access and subscription management by text | Retention features and offers built into the app |
| Portal and cancel flow | Customizable portal and cancellation flows | Portal flows and cancellation offers | Portal and cancel flow options | Retention offers in portal and cancel flow |
| Easier login | Check current login options | Check current login options | A focus for Skio, check details | Check current login options |
| SMS for subscribers | Offers its own SMS features, check scope | Check current SMS options | SMS is a big part of the product | Check current SMS options |
| Ask the vendor | Exact Klaviyo metric list for your plan | Exact Klaviyo metric list and profile properties | Which SMS messages overlap with Klaviyo | Which offers fire when, and whether that data reaches Klaviyo |
Recharge
Recharge has been around the longest of the four, and its Klaviyo integration is widely used. A lot of agencies and freelancers know it well, which makes hiring help easier. It comes with its own customer notifications and its own SMS features, so on a Recharge account the first job is deciding which messages stay in Recharge and which move to Klaviyo. We cover that split in our subscription email guide.
What to check: the exact metrics your plan sends, how the cancellation flow is set up today, and which notifications are switched on.
Loop
Loop is built for Shopify brands and puts a lot of weight on the customer portal and on retention flows when someone tries to cancel. From the email side, the question is which Loop events and properties land in Klaviyo and whether the product and next order date come through for personalization. We wrote a separate guide on setting up Loop Subscriptions with Klaviyo.
What to check: the event list in Klaviyo after connecting, the portal flows a subscriber sees, and which Loop notifications overlap with your Klaviyo flows.
Skio
Skio leans into making the subscriber's life easy, with easier portal access and subscription management by text as visible parts of the product. That's good news for your order reminders, because a reminder that leads straight into a working portal gets acted on. It also means you have two systems that might text the same person, Skio and Klaviyo, so you need a clear plan for who sends what.
What to check: how portal links behave when clicked from an email, which SMS features are on, and which Skio data reaches Klaviyo.
Stay AI
Stay AI positions itself around retention, with offers and logic inside the app aimed at keeping subscribers from churning. For email, that's both helpful and something to manage. If the app already makes an offer at cancellation, your Klaviyo flow must know about it, or the subscriber gets two different deals for the same decision.
What to check: which offers the app shows and when, and whether accepted or declined offers reach Klaviyo as data.
Migration effort, from the email side
The vendors handle moving subscriptions and payment methods, and most of them offer migration help. Ask what's included. What they won't do is fix your Klaviyo account. On the day the old app stops sending events, these break without any warning:
- Every flow triggered by an old subscription metric
- Segments built on old properties like subscription status
- Flow filters that exclude subscribers from one-time buyer flows
- Campaign exclusions that keep subscribers away from first-order offers
Before the switch, list all of these. Rebuild them on the new app's metrics, pause the old flows instead of deleting them, and test each event with a real test subscription after the switch. If you run a lot of subscription flows, give this a full week.
Questions to ask in every demo
- Which Klaviyo metrics and profile properties does your integration send today?
- Does the cancellation reason reach Klaviyo?
- Which customer notifications can we switch off if Klaviyo takes over?
- How does a subscriber log in to the portal from an email link?
- What does your migration support cover, and what's left for us?
Get the answers in writing. Then check them yourself in a test store if you can.
If you're planning a switch and want someone to handle the Klaviyo side, our subscription marketing service covers flow rebuilds and migration audits.
Questions we get a lot
Which subscription app works best with Klaviyo?
Recharge, Loop, Skio and Stay AI all have Klaviyo integrations that send subscription events. The differences are in which events and properties arrive and how much you can do in the portal. Ask each vendor for their current list of Klaviyo metrics and properties and compare those directly.
Is it hard to migrate from Recharge to Loop or Skio?
The vendors handle most of the subscription and payment migration and usually offer help with it. On the email side, every Klaviyo flow, segment and filter built on Recharge metrics has to be rebuilt on the new app's metrics. Plan a full audit of your flows before the switch date.
Do these apps offer passwordless login for subscribers?
Several subscription apps offer some form of easier login to the customer portal, like magic links or text-based access, but the details differ and change. Check each vendor's current documentation and test the login yourself as a subscriber would.
Should the subscription app or Klaviyo send emails to subscribers?
Usually Klaviyo sends the emails that sell or retain, like order reminders, failed payment and cancellation follow-ups. The app keeps transactional messages Klaviyo doesn't replace. Whatever you pick, switch off the duplicate notification on the other side.