Campaigns

The testimonial email: what to send when you don't know what to send.

Your customers already wrote the email for you. You just have to put enough of their reviews in one place.

On November 12, Leon posted a fix for the week when nothing is planned: just send a testimonial email that showcases a ton of reviews. His example came from Supergoop, an email headed "The reviews are in... and everyone loves Dewscreen." There's no launch in it and no discount. The customers do the selling.

Why the testimonial email works

Social proof is one of the seven campaign types we plan every calendar around. And it's often the highest converting email that doesn't carry a discount.

It makes sense when you look at how people buy now. Shoppers compare 4 to 5 brands before they order, and reading reviews is one of the last stops before the purchase. A testimonial email brings that step into the inbox.

It also fixes a calendar problem. We aim for about 70% value emails and 30% promotional, so the weeks between sales need content that still sells. A review email fills that slot, and you already have the material sitting in your review app.

How we structure a testimonial email

We build it as a designed email, with 2 to 4 blocks:

  1. Hero. One headline about the reviews, a short subheader, a star row and the main button. The Supergoop headline is a good model, because it tells you the whole story before you scroll.
  2. Review section. Starts with a ★★★★★ row, then 2 to 3 quotes with first names, and ages where you have them.
  3. Second review section (optional). Leon's point is volume. A second stack of quotes, ideally answering a different worry than the first.
  4. Product block. A headline, a one-line bridge from the reviews, the product name, a few short bullets and the button.

Keep it to one product. One message and one main button per email, so the reader knows exactly where to go. Got strong reviews for several products? Save the others for next month's testimonial email.

Picking the reviews

  • Word for word. We never paraphrase a customer. If a review only works after editing, it's the wrong review.
  • Answer an objection. The best quotes deal with a doubt people actually have, like whether it actually works or whether it's worth the price.
  • Specific beats nice. "Love it" is filler. A review with a timeline and a result does the work.
  • Real names. First name, and age if the customer shared it. Anonymous praise reads like marketing.
Supplement and health brandsA testimonial can't make a claim your brand couldn't make itself. If a customer writes that your product cured something, putting that in an email means you're making a disease claim. Pick a different quote.

Variations so it doesn't get stale

If you send a testimonial email every few weeks, change the format each time. These come from our campaign idea swipe file:

IdeaWhat it looks like
Reviews round-upA stack of strong reviews, like the Supergoop email
One reviewA single long review with a good story, unpacked line by line
Customer spotlightReal customer photos and what changed for them
RedditScreenshots of real people talking about the product
Before and afterReal customer results, side by side

Subject lines for a testimonial email

Two from our swipe file that fit this email well: "Everyone's talking about [product]..." and "Do Our Products Really Work??". Both make people curious about what customers said. Keep the subject different from the hero headline, so the email adds something after the open. Our subject line guide has the full rules.

Where else testimonials belong

Campaigns are only half of it. In most of our flows, the fourth email is a social proof email, right before the last offer expires. You can see that backbone in our Klaviyo flows guide.

The abandoned checkout flow works with just one testimonial. One specific quote that matches what the person almost bought, next to the expiring discount. We break that down in the abandoned cart flow guide.

And reviews aren't the only proof you can show. Badges, press mentions, clinician recommendations and Reddit threads work the same way, which we cover in trust badges and social proof.

One place they don't belong is SMS. Texts work for drops, restocks, flash sales and announcements. Social proof goes by email.

Watch Leon walk through it

Free on YouTube, in German.

Questions we get a lot

What is a testimonial email?

A campaign built around customer reviews instead of an offer. Real customer quotes and star ratings, with a link to the product people are talking about.

How many reviews should a testimonial email include?

Leon's tip is to show a lot of them. We use 2 to 3 verbatim quotes per review section and up to two review sections, plus a star row in the hero.

Can I edit customer reviews before using them in an email?

No. Use reviews word for word. If a review needs fixing to work, pick a different review.

Should testimonials go out by SMS too?

No. Social proof belongs in email. We keep SMS for drops, restocks, flash sales and announcements.

Want to see where your extra revenue is?

Book a free 30 minute audit. We go through your Klaviyo together and show you what we would change first.

Get a free audit