A subscriber opens the Stay AI portal to cancel, gets offered 20% off the next order, declines, and confirms. Ten minutes later Klaviyo sends them 15% off to stay. That subscriber now knows you'll negotiate, and they've also learned your emails don't know what just happened. Stay AI email marketing is mostly about avoiding that moment: connecting the app's events to Klaviyo so every flow knows what the subscriber already saw.
Below is how we set up Klaviyo for brands on Stay AI. The events to look for, the flow on each, timing, and how to split messages and offers between the app and the inbox. Our subscription email marketing guide covers the strategy that sits above all of this.
What Stay AI sends to Klaviyo
When the Stay AI integration is connected, subscription activity appears in Klaviyo as metrics, and subscriber data like status or next order date can land on the profile. What exactly arrives depends on your Stay AI configuration, and integrations change over time. So check the metric names in your own Klaviyo account and in the Stay AI docs. We describe the moments in general terms here:
- A subscription is created
- An order is about to process
- A payment fails
- An order is skipped
- A subscription is cancelled
Also look for anything retention-related on the profile. If Stay AI passes data about offers a subscriber accepted or a cancellation reason, that changes what your flows can do. If it doesn't, ask Stay AI support whether it's available before you build around a guess.
The Stay AI email marketing flows we build
| Event | Flow | Goal | Timing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Subscription created | Subscription welcome | Explain what ships, when, and how to change it | Right away, second email 3 to 4 days later |
| Upcoming order | Order reminder | No surprise charges, easy skip or swap | 3 to 5 days before the order |
| Payment failed | Failed payment | Recover the payment before the order is lost | Within hours, then follow-ups over about a week |
| Order skipped | Skip follow-up | Offer a better interval or product | 1 day after the skip |
| Subscription cancelled | Cancellation follow-up | Learn why, offer a fix the portal didn't | Within 24 hours |
| Subscription cancelled | Win-back | Restart the subscription later | Starts 3 to 6 weeks after the cancel |
Order reminder
Put the date, amount and products right at the top, then a skip link and a swap link. That's the whole email. Don't bury it under a product launch or a blog post.
If Stay AI or your portal offers add-ons or product swaps, you can show one relevant option here. Keep it to one. The reminder exists so nobody gets charged by surprise, and three upsells make it feel like an ad.
Check who sends this today. Stay AI has its own notifications, and if Klaviyo sends a reminder too, people get two.
Failed payment
Payment retries happen inside Stay AI. Klaviyo adds the part that needs a person's attention: a short email with a direct link to update the card, then a few follow-ups over the next week. Before each follow-up, check whether the payment has gone through so you stop as soon as it's fixed.
For high-value subscribers, a plain text email from someone on the team often works better than a designed one. You can split on order value or number of orders in the flow.
Skip follow-up and welcome
One email after a skip is enough. Suggest a longer interval or a different product. And in the welcome, make the controls obvious: how to skip, how to swap, how to change the date. People who know they can change things easily tend to stick around longer.
Cancellation follow-up and win-back
This is where the coordination matters most. The Stay AI cancel flow may already show offers before someone confirms, like a pause, a swap or a discount. By the time the cancel event reaches Klaviyo, the subscriber has seen those and said no.
So the follow-up email shouldn't repeat them. Ask a real question instead, from a real person, and offer something the portal didn't, maybe a smaller size or a different product. If the cancel reason arrives as a property, split on it.
The win-back flow starts weeks later. Lead with what's new, link directly to restarting where that's possible, and space the emails out. More detail in our win-back flow guide.
Keep app offers and email offers in sync
Many subscription apps now make retention offers on their own, and Stay AI puts real emphasis on this. That's useful, but it means your discounts can come from two places. Before you write a single offer in Klaviyo, list what the app can show and when:
- Offers in the cancel flow
- Offers or swaps in the customer portal
- Any automatic discounts on later orders
Then plan Klaviyo around that list. If the portal already offers a discount at cancellation, the email follow-up leads with a non-discount fix. If the portal offers a pause, the email can offer a swap. Each decision a subscriber makes should come with one offer, and the same one wherever they look.
Check Stay AI's current documentation for what your plan includes, because the retention features in these apps change often.
Notifications: who sends what
| Message | Usually sent by | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Order reminder | Klaviyo | Turn off the Stay AI email version |
| Failed payment | Klaviyo | Align with the retry schedule in Stay AI |
| Cancellation follow-up | Klaviyo | Plan around the portal cancel flow offers |
| Login and account messages | Stay AI or Shopify | Leave as they are |
After switching things off, test with a real subscription. Trigger each event and see what arrives. Two emails for one event means a notification is still on somewhere.
Campaigns and segments
Use the Stay AI data to build segments for active subscribers, cancelled subscribers and one-time buyers. Exclude active subscribers from first-order discounts. And watch your regular post-purchase flow so recurring orders don't trigger first-purchase emails. Our Klaviyo flows guide shows how the subscription flows fit next to the rest of your automations.
If you want a team that builds and runs this for you, that's our subscription marketing service.
Questions we get a lot
Does Stay AI integrate with Klaviyo?
Yes. Stay AI has a Klaviyo integration that passes subscription events and subscriber data into Klaviyo. The exact metrics and properties depend on your setup, so check the metrics list in your Klaviyo account and the Stay AI documentation before you build flows.
Which Stay AI events should trigger Klaviyo flows?
The upcoming order, a failed payment, a cancellation, a skipped order and a new subscription. Build the first three before anything else, because they decide most of your churn.
How do I stop Stay AI and Klaviyo from sending double emails?
List every notification Stay AI sends, decide per message which system owns it, and switch off the Stay AI version of anything Klaviyo now covers. Then trigger each event with a test subscription and check the inbox.
Can Klaviyo emails and Stay AI retention offers clash?
They can, if both offer a discount at the same moment. Find out which offers the Stay AI portal and cancel flow show, then plan your Klaviyo offers around them so a subscriber never sees two different deals for the same decision.