Subscriptions

Subscription pricing: how to set a discount you can keep paying.

Most brands copy the subscription discount a competitor shows and never check it against their own margin. Here is how we work out a price with clients, and how to test it without burning existing subscribers.

A subscriber who stays for 8 orders at a 15% discount gets the same discount 8 times. That is the part of subscription pricing most brands skip: the discount is not a one-off acquisition cost like a welcome code, it repeats on every order for as long as the subscriber stays. So the question is less "what makes people sign up" and more "what can we afford to give on every single order and still be happy."

This guide is about how we work through that with clients. We will not hand you a magic percentage, because there is none. Your margin, your product and your customers decide it.

Start with margin per order

Before you look at any competitor, write down what one order earns you. For a typical subscription order that means:

  • Price the customer pays
  • Minus product cost
  • Minus shipping and packaging, especially if subscriptions ship free
  • Minus payment fees and subscription app fees

What is left is your contribution margin per order. The subscription discount comes straight out of this number.

An example to show the math, with made up numbers. A product sells for $40. Product cost is $10, shipping and packaging $7, fees $2. That leaves $21. A 15% subscription discount costs $6 per order and leaves $15. A 25% discount costs $10 and leaves $11. On paper both still make money. But if you also give free shipping only to subscribers, or your costs rise next year, the 25% version gets thin quickly.

Run this for your real numbers before you pick a discount. If the margin after the discount is close to zero, the subscription only works if subscribers stay a very long time or buy add-ons, and you should not plan on that.

Bring in lifetime value

The point of a subscription is that customers order more often and for longer than they would on their own. So compare two things for the same product:

  • What a one-time buyer is worth over a year at full price, counting the reorders they make on their own
  • What a subscriber is worth over a year at the discounted price, counting how long subscribers actually stay

If the subscriber number is clearly higher, the discount pays for itself. If they are close, you are mostly giving a discount to people who would have reordered anyway. Our guide to subscription LTV goes through how to calculate both, and the LTV calculator does the arithmetic for you.

For a brand that is just launching a subscription, you will not have retention data yet. Use your repeat purchase rate as a rough stand-in and recheck once you have three or four months of subscriber data.

First order discount vs ongoing discount

These do different jobs, and mixing them up causes most pricing problems we see.

StructureWhat it does wellThe risk
Big first order discount, small ongoing oneGets people to try the subscriptionMany cancel right after the first order, since the reason to join is gone
Same discount on every orderSimple to explain, rewards stayingLess pull on the first order
Small ongoing discount plus a one-time extra on the first orderSome pull up front, margin protected laterTwo numbers to communicate clearly

A heavy first order offer looks great in a sign up report. Then you look at how many of those subscribers reached their second and third order and it looks less great. If you run a first order offer, judge it on retention, not on sign ups.

One more thing to watch: if your welcome popup already gives a discount on the first order, think about how it stacks with the subscription discount. Many brands accidentally give two discounts on the first subscription order.

Tiered discounts that grow with order count

A tiered discount starts small and grows as the subscriber stays. For example, a lower price from the fourth order on, and lower again from the eighth. The numbers here are illustrations, not a recommendation.

Why we like it:

  • Early orders are when cancels are most likely. A smaller discount there costs you less on people who leave anyway.
  • Long-term subscribers, the ones who make up most of your recurring revenue, get the best price.
  • It gives your emails something to talk about. "Your next order is your 4th, and from here your price drops" is a real reason to keep a subscription.

Two practical points. First, check that your subscription app supports discounts by order number, because not all of them do it the same way. Second, explain the tiers at sign up, on the product page and in the welcome email. A reward the subscriber does not know about does not keep anyone. Our guide to the subscription loyalty program covers how to announce milestones in Klaviyo.

Free gifts instead of discounts

A gift can do the job of a discount at a lower cost to you. A branded tin with the first coffee order, or a sample of a new product on order five.

Why it can work better:

  • The perceived value to the customer is often higher than what the item costs you.
  • It does not lower the price anchor. When the gift period is over, the price stays where it was.

And a sample of another product sometimes turns into an add-on or a swap later.

The downside is complexity. Gifts need stock, fulfilment rules and a way to make sure each subscriber gets each gift once. Before you promise one, check how your subscription app and your warehouse handle it.

Some brands go further and drop the price discount entirely, keeping only free shipping and gifts. That works best when the product is clearly better than alternatives and the convenience is the main reason to subscribe.

Show the price in real numbers

Whatever you choose, show it in currency on the product page and in your emails. "$40 one time or $34 with subscription" is clear. "Save 15%" makes the customer do math, and most will not. If subscriptions ship free and one-time orders do not, add that to the comparison too.

If you run tiers, a small table on the product page helps: orders 1 to 3 at one price, 4 onward at a lower one. Keep it short.

How to test subscription pricing

Pricing tests on subscriptions take longer than most tests, because the result you care about shows up months later. Some rules we stick to:

  1. Test on new subscribers only. Changing the price for existing subscribers is a separate decision. It can trigger cancels, and in some markets you need a valid clause in your terms to do it. Ask a lawyer before you raise prices on existing subscriptions.
  2. Change one thing at a time. Discount level first, or the first order offer, but not both in the same test.
  3. Measure past the first order. Look at sign up rate, then retention to the second and third order, then revenue per subscriber over at least a few months.
  4. Split by time if you cannot split by visitor. Many subscription apps do not support price A/B tests. Running one structure for a period, then the other, is less clean but still useful if nothing else big changes at the same time.

Write down your numbers before you start: margin per order at each price, and the retention you would need for the new structure to beat the old one. Then you know what result would make you switch, before you see the data.

Mistakes we see often

  • Copying a competitor's discount. Their margin, shipping costs and retention are not yours.
  • Raising the discount to fix churn. If subscribers leave because they have too much product or a delivery went wrong, a bigger discount fixes nothing. Look at the reasons first. Our guide to reducing subscription churn covers that.
  • Discount creep in save offers. Every cancel attempt gets another discount, and soon long-term subscribers pay less than anyone else for the wrong reason. Match save offers to the reason, as described in our cancellation flow guide.
  • Forgetting the stack. Welcome code plus subscription discount plus a sitewide sale on the same order.
Where to startTake your best seller and write down the margin per order at full price, then at your current or planned subscription discount. Next to it, write how many orders a subscriber needs to stay to beat a one-time buyer. If that number looks unrealistic, change the structure before you change anything else. If you want help with the setup, see our subscription marketing service.

Questions we get a lot

How big should a subscription discount be?

There is no number that fits every brand. Work backwards from your contribution margin per order after product cost, shipping, payment fees and packaging. The discount has to leave enough margin on every repeat order, not just the first, and it has to be big enough that customers notice it in the price.

Is a big first order discount better than an ongoing subscription discount?

It brings in more sign ups, but often more people who cancel right after the first order. An ongoing discount rewards staying. Many brands combine a modest ongoing discount with a small extra on the first order, and then check how many subscribers reach their third order.

What are tiered subscription discounts?

A discount that grows with the number of orders, for example a lower price from the fourth order on. It rewards tenure and protects your margin early on, when cancels are most likely. Your subscription app has to support it, so check that before you plan it.

How do I test subscription pricing?

Test on new subscribers only, one change at a time, and run it long enough to see second and third orders, not just sign ups. Changing the price for existing subscribers is a separate decision with its own risks, and in some markets with legal requirements.

Want to see where your extra revenue is?

Book a free 30 minute audit. We go through your Klaviyo together and show you what we would change first.

Get a free audit