Subscriptions

The best Shopify subscription apps for email and retention.

There is no single best subscription app. There is the one that gives your Klaviyo account the data it needs and makes it easy for subscribers to stay. Here is how we look at seven of them.

Search for the best Shopify subscription apps and you'll find a lot of lists ranked by price and star rating. Useful for billing. Less useful if your question is which app makes it easiest to keep subscribers past month three. That part happens in Klaviyo, and it only works as well as the data and the customer portal the subscription app gives you.

So this overview looks at seven apps from one angle: how easy each one makes email and retention. We don't rank them or quote prices. Features change quickly in this category, so check current features with each vendor before you decide.

What makes a subscription app good for email

When we start working with a subscription brand, these are the questions we ask about their app. They're the same questions we'd ask before choosing one.

  • Klaviyo events. Does the app send events for a new subscription, an upcoming order, a failed payment, a skip and a cancellation?
  • Profile properties. Do subscription status, next order date, products and the cancellation reason land on the Klaviyo profile?
  • Customer portal. Can a subscriber skip, swap or change the date in one or two taps from an email link?
  • Cancel flow. Does the app show alternatives before someone confirms, and can you see what was offered?
  • Notifications. Can you switch off the app's own emails one by one when Klaviyo takes over?

Every flow in our subscription email marketing guide depends on these answers. An app that sends rich data and has an easy portal makes all of it simpler.

The apps at a glance

This table shows how each app generally positions itself and what we would check first. It reflects how the vendors describe themselves, so treat it as a checklist.

AppKlaviyoGenerally known forCheck first
RechargeIntegration, long establishedOne of the most widely used subscription apps on ShopifyExact metric list for your plan, overlapping notifications
LoopIntegrationCustomer portal and retention flowsWhich events and properties reach Klaviyo
SkioIntegrationEasy portal access and subscription management by textHow Skio SMS and Klaviyo SMS split the work
Stay AIIntegrationRetention offers built into the appWhich offers fire when, and whether Klaviyo sees them
SmartrrCheck current docsBranded subscriber experienceEvent coverage in Klaviyo
AppstleCheck current docsBroad feature set for many store sizesEvent coverage and profile properties
SealCheck current docsOften named as a simple option to get startedEvent coverage and notification settings

Recharge

Recharge is the name most people know, and its Klaviyo integration has been in use for years. That brings a practical advantage: many freelancers, agencies and templates already assume Recharge data. It has its own notifications and SMS features, so plan who sends what. Our subscription emails guide shows the split we use.

Loop

Loop puts a lot of focus on the customer portal and on retention flows at cancellation. For email, that means fewer subscribers reach the cancel button in the first place, and your Klaviyo flows can focus on reminders and win-backs. We wrote a full setup guide for Loop Subscriptions and Klaviyo.

Skio

Skio is known for making the subscriber side easy, with simpler portal access and subscription management by text. A reminder email that leads into a portal people can actually get into is worth a lot. The thing to plan is SMS: if Skio texts subscribers and Klaviyo does too, decide clearly which messages come from where.

Stay AI

Stay AI focuses on retention inside the app, with offers built around stopping churn before it happens. That can lighten the load on your email flows. It also means you have to coordinate, because a Klaviyo discount on top of an app discount at the same moment confuses people and costs margin.

Smartrr

Smartrr positions itself around the branded subscriber experience. From the email side, check how it connects to Klaviyo, which events arrive and whether the portal links work well from an email. Ask for a test account if you can.

Appstle

Appstle is used by a wide range of store sizes and offers a broad set of subscription features. Before you commit, look at which subscription events and profile properties Appstle sends to Klaviyo, and whether you can turn off its own customer emails individually.

Seal

Seal often comes up as a simple way to get subscriptions running. If you plan to build a full set of subscription flows in Klaviyo, check early whether the events you need are available, since your flows depend on them.

Shopify also offers its own subscriptions app. If you're considering it, ask the same questions about Klaviyo data and the portal.

How we'd choose, from the email side

If a client asked us to help pick, we'd do it in this order:

  • Shortlist two or three apps that fit your size and product.
  • Ask each vendor for the exact list of Klaviyo metrics and profile properties they send today.
  • Click through the portal as a subscriber. Count the taps to skip, swap and change the date.
  • Walk through the cancel flow and note every offer it shows.
  • Check that each customer notification can be switched off separately.

The app that does best on those points will make your Klaviyo work easiest. Once it's live, build segments on subscription status so campaigns treat subscribers and one-time buyers differently. Our segmentation guide shows how.

If you're already on an app

Switching is a big job on the email side. Every flow, segment and filter built on your current app's data needs rebuilding, and nothing warns you when the old ones stop firing. So before you move, check whether the problem is really the app. Often the events are there and the flows were simply never built, or the app's notifications are doubling up with Klaviyo.

If you want someone to look at that with you, or to build the flows on whichever app you choose, that's what our subscription marketing service is for.

Try thisBefore any demo, write down the five subscription moments you care about: new subscription, upcoming order, failed payment, skip, cancel. Ask every vendor to show you each one arriving in Klaviyo. The answers sort the list faster than any review.

Questions we get a lot

What is the best Shopify subscription app?

It depends on your size, your product and your team. From the email side, the best app is the one that sends the subscription events and properties you need into Klaviyo and has a portal where skipping or swapping takes one tap. Compare the apps on those points with a demo or a test store.

Which Shopify subscription apps work with Klaviyo?

Recharge, Loop, Skio and Stay AI all have Klaviyo integrations. Smartrr, Appstle and Seal are also used alongside Klaviyo, but check each one's current documentation for which events and properties actually reach Klaviyo before you decide.

Do I need a subscription app if I already use Klaviyo?

Yes. Klaviyo sends emails and texts, but it doesn't bill recurring orders. The subscription app handles billing and the customer portal, and passes events to Klaviyo so your flows can react.

Is it worth switching subscription apps?

Only if the current app blocks something important, like missing Klaviyo events, a portal that pushes people to cancel, or features your team needs. A switch means rebuilding every Klaviyo flow, segment and filter that uses the old app's data, so plan for that work.

Want to see where your extra revenue is?

Book a free 30 minute audit. We go through your Klaviyo together and show you what we would change first.

Get a free audit