Strategy

Direct mail for ecommerce: who gets a postcard and when.

A postcard costs more than an email ever will. So it only goes to customers who are worth it, at the moment email couldn't reach them. Here is how we set it up.

Email costs you close to nothing per send. A postcard costs real money every single time. That one difference decides how direct mail for ecommerce should work. The card goes to a small group of customers at a specific moment, after email had its chance. And then you measure whether it earned its postage.

Why triggered mail beats the big catalogue drop

The old way is a seasonal mailer to every address in the database. Most of it goes to people who would have bought anyway, or who will never buy again. Triggered direct mail flips that. A card goes out when something happens in your customer data: a high-value customer goes quiet, a subscriber reaches a milestone, a VIP is due for a thank-you.

The trigger lives where the rest of your automation lives, in Klaviyo. That way the postcard sits inside the same flow as the emails and texts, and it knows what those already said.

Which segments get mail

Every segment has to pass one question: is this customer worth clearly more to you than the card costs? That leaves a short list.

SegmentTriggerWhat the card does
Lapsed high-value customersNo order for longer than their usual reorder gap, after the winback emails got no reactionReminds them you exist, with a reason or an offer to come back
VIPsReaching your top spend tier, or a set number of ordersSays thank you, gives early access or a small extra
Subscribers at riskSkipped deliveries, a visit to the cancellation page or a failed payment that got fixed lateOffers a pause or a product swap before they cancel
Subscription milestonesA set number of deliveries or monthsThanks them at the point where many start to rethink the subscription
First-time buyersA few days after the first deliveryA thank-you card that makes the second order more likely

To build these segments cleanly, you need spend and order history on the profile, plus subscription events if you sell subscriptions. Our Klaviyo segmentation guide shows how we set that up. Who stays off the list matters just as much. People who never bought stay on email, and anyone who objected to postal advertising gets nothing by post, ever.

Timing next to your email flows

Mail is slow. Between the trigger and the letterbox the card has to be printed and then delivered by the postal service, and that can take days, depending on the platform and the country. So the card always comes after the cheaper channels.

In a winback flow, that looks like this. The emails run first, usually with the offer coming in from the second one. Only customers who didn't order or even click move into the mail branch. The card goes out then, and the email flow pauses so the two don't talk over each other. When the card has had time to arrive, one more email can follow and point to it. The full email side is in our winback flow guide.

Post-purchase works the other way around. The thank-you card goes out so it lands a few days after the package, once the customer has actually used the product. Our post-purchase flow guide covers the emails it sits between.

One rule for all of them: if the card carries an offer, the offer has to be valid when the card arrives, and for a while after. A code that expired two days before the postcard hit the mat is worse than no card at all.

Offer and creative

A postcard has a few seconds on the way from the letterbox to the bin. It needs one message the reader gets at a glance.

  • One idea per card. A thank-you card that also pushes a new product does neither well. Pick one.
  • The product, big. A photo of what they bought before works better than a lifestyle shot they won't connect to you.
  • A short way to act. A short URL or a QR code that goes straight to a prefilled cart or a landing page. Nobody types a long link.
  • A unique code. One code per customer or per segment, so you can trace orders back to the card.
  • A human note. Thank-you and VIP cards work better when they sound like the founder wrote them by hand.

Not every card needs a discount. For VIPs and first-time buyers, a real thank-you often does the job, and it keeps your margins intact. Save the offers for lapsed customers and at-risk subscribers, where you actually need a push.

And keep the copy native. If you mail into several countries, each card gets written in that language from the start, with local address formats and local postal rules in mind.

Measuring with holdout groups

Codes alone undercount direct mail. Plenty of people see the card, then go to your site later and order without the code, or click an email that arrived the same week. Last-click reporting gives that order to the email.

So every mail segment gets a holdout. A random share of the people who qualify gets no card. Everything else stays the same for both groups. After a fixed period you compare revenue per customer between the mailed group and the holdout. The difference, minus what the cards cost, is what direct mail really added.

A few rules keep the test honest. Split randomly, never by hand. Keep the holdout large enough to compare. Measure over a window that fits your reorder cycle, so a slow buyer still counts. And keep the holdout running, because a segment that paid off in spring can stop paying off by autumn.

What a piece costs, in general terms

We won't put numbers here, because they change by format, volume, platform and country. What stays the same is how the cost is built. You pay for printing and postage. Depending on the platform, there's also a fee per piece or a subscription on top. Postage is usually the biggest part, and it's set by the postal service in each country.

A bigger card or a folded mailer costs more than a standard postcard. Higher volumes often bring the print price down. Mailing abroad usually costs more than mailing at home. So get current quotes from a few platforms for your own markets, then work out the break-even: how much extra revenue per mailed customer you need to cover the card. That number tells you which segments are worth mailing.

Which platformDepending on your account and market, Klaviyo may offer its own direct mail option. Platforms like PostPilot, Postie, Lob and Poplar print and send mail based on customer data, and several connect to Klaviyo or Shopify. Features and supported countries change, so check each one's current docs. If you want us to set this up for you, see our direct mail service.

A note on rules

Postal advertising has its own rules, and they differ by country. In many places you can mail existing customers based on legitimate interest, as long as they can object easily and you stop when they do. Abandoned cart postcards to people who never bought are a different case and often not allowed. This isn't legal advice, so check your setup for each market with your legal advisor before the first card goes out.

Questions we get a lot

Which customers should get direct mail?

Customers whose value is clearly higher than the cost of a piece of mail. In practice that means lapsed customers who used to spend a lot, plus subscribers who show signs of cancelling. VIPs get the occasional thank-you card too. New subscribers who never bought usually stay on email.

Should direct mail replace a winback email flow?

No. The emails go first because they cost almost nothing. The postcard follows only for the people who didn't react to the emails, so you pay postage for the smallest possible group.

How do I know if direct mail actually works?

Use a holdout group. Pick a random share of the segment that gets no mail, then compare revenue per customer between the mailed group and the holdout over the same period. Codes on the card help, but they miss people who order without using them.

How much does a postcard cost per piece?

It depends on the format, the print volume, the platform and the country you mail to. Postage is usually the biggest part. Get current quotes from a few print and mail platforms for your own markets before you plan the budget.

Want to see where your extra revenue is?

Book a free 30 minute audit. We go through your Klaviyo together and show you what we would change first.

Get a free audit