Strategy

How to grow an email and SMS list that actually buys.

More sign-ups are easy to get. Sign-ups who later buy are harder. These are the list growth channels we set up for DTC brands, and the ones we treat with care.

On a typical DTC store, around 97 or 98 out of every 100 visitors leave without buying, and most of them never come back on their own. The ones who leave an email address on the way out are the only part of that traffic you can reach again for free. That's the whole case for working on how you grow an email list for ecommerce: you already paid for the visit, so the sign-up is cheap. The harder part is getting sign-ups who later buy.

To grow an email list for ecommerce, start with the pop-up

On nearly every account we take over, the pop-up is the biggest list source by a wide margin. So that's where we start. The full setup is in our pop-up guide. The short version:

  • Lead with a clear offer. A percentage off, free shipping, or a gift with the first order. Whatever it is, the visitor should understand it in one glance.
  • Time it. Showing the pop-up the second someone lands annoys people and hurts mobile experience. We usually trigger it after some time on site or some scroll depth, plus an exit intent version on desktop.
  • Test the offer before the design. Moving from 10% off to free shipping, or to a gift, often matters more than any color or headline change.

Make it two-step

A two-step form asks for one thing at a time. Step one asks for the email. Step two asks for the phone number for SMS, with a line like "Want your code by text too?" Someone who skips step two is still on your email list. Ask for both on one screen and some people leave without giving you either.

You can also use the first step as a soft yes. A button like "Yes, I want 10% off" before any field appears gets people to commit with one tap, and the email field comes after.

Quizzes and zero-party data

A product quiz asks shoppers about themselves: skin type, dog size, coffee taste, whatever fits the category. At the end you ask for the email to send the result. People are happy to give it, because the result is useful to them.

The bigger win is what comes with the email. Each answer can be saved to the Klaviyo profile as a property. That is zero-party data, information the customer told you directly. Now the welcome emails can talk about their skin type instead of skin in general, and your campaigns can be split by what people actually said. A quiz takes more work to build than a pop-up, so it makes the most sense for brands where choosing the right product is genuinely hard.

Checkout opt-in

Shopify checkout has a box for email marketing consent, and you can add one for SMS. Keep both unticked by default and let the customer decide. The volume is lower than from the pop-up, but these subscribers already paid you once.

Don't forget to check that the consent really syncs into Klaviyo. We regularly find stores where checkout subscribers sit in Shopify with consent while Klaviyo never got them onto the list.

Post-purchase SMS opt-in

Many customers skip the SMS box at checkout because they're focused on paying. Right after the order is a better moment to ask again. A form on the thank-you page works, and so does a line in the shipping confirmation: "Want delivery updates by text? Tap here." Shipping updates are a reason people actually want texts, and once they've opted in, they can get your campaigns too, as long as your consent wording covers marketing. Our SMS marketing guide covers consent and frequency.

Giveaways and their list-quality problem

Giveaways can add thousands of contacts in a week. A lot of them signed up for a free TV or a stack of gift cards and have no interest in your product. They open the "you didn't win" email and then nothing. Those contacts lower your engagement rates and, when they start marking you as spam, your sender reputation.

If you run one anyway, a few rules help:

  • Give away your own product or something very close to it. A year's supply of your coffee attracts coffee drinkers. An iPad attracts everyone.
  • Tag the source on every profile so you can tell giveaway sign-ups apart later.
  • Use a separate welcome flow that introduces the brand properly before you sell.
  • Keep them out of your main campaigns until they've clicked or bought. If they never do, your sunset process takes care of them.

Partner giveaways with brands that share your audience usually bring better quality than big public ones, because the people entering already buy in your category.

Landing pages for paid traffic

If you run ads to cold audiences, not every click is ready to buy. Sending some of that traffic to a landing page built around a sign-up gives you a second shot at the people who aren't. That might be a guide, a quiz, early access to a launch or a waitlist for a sold out product. Keep the page to a single offer, and put the form where mobile visitors see it without scrolling.

Compare these pages on cost per subscriber and on how many of those subscribers buy within 30 or 60 days. A cheap sign-up who never orders isn't a win.

What to do with new subscribers

Every source above should feed a welcome flow on the day someone signs up. That's when interest is highest. If you collect the sign-up source and quiz answers as profile properties, the welcome flow can split by source and talk to each group differently. Our welcome flow guide shows the structure we use.

The number to watchTotal list size looks nice in a report and says very little. Track new subscribers per month by source, and what share of each source places a first order within 60 days. That tells you which channels to grow and which ones are just adding names.

Questions we get a lot

What is the fastest way to grow an email list for an ecommerce store?

A well-built pop-up with a clear offer. On most stores it brings in more subscribers than every other source combined. Make it two-step, test the offer, and set the timing so it doesn't hit people the second they land.

Are giveaways a good way to grow an email list?

They bring in a lot of sign-ups fast, but many of those people want the prize, not your product. Run them only with a prize close to your own product, and send the new contacts through a separate welcome flow so they don't drag down your engaged segments.

Should I ask for email and phone number in the same form?

Ask for the email first and the phone number on a second step. Asking for both at once usually costs you sign-ups. With two steps you keep the email even when someone skips the phone number.

Do checkout opt-ins count as real subscribers?

Yes, as long as the box is unticked by default and the customer checks it. These subscribers already bought from you, so they are some of the most valuable people on the list.

Want to see where your extra revenue is?

Book a free 30 minute audit. We go through your Klaviyo together and show you what we would change first.

Get a free audit