On a renewal day, some share of your subscribers' cards will decline. Maybe the card expired, maybe there just wasn't enough money on the account that morning. None of these people clicked cancel. If nobody tells them, the platform runs out of retries and the subscription ends anyway. Failed payment recovery emails exist to catch them before that happens.
This kind of loss is called involuntary churn, and it's the easiest churn to fix, because the subscriber is on your side. You don't need to convince anyone. You need to tell them clearly and make the fix take thirty seconds.
Why cards decline
It helps to know what you're dealing with, because the reason shapes the message.
- Expired card. Very common on subscriptions that run a year or longer. The subscriber has a new card and simply never updated it with you.
- Insufficient funds. Often temporary. A retry a few days later, after payday, frequently goes through on its own.
- Bank decline or fraud block. The bank stopped a charge it didn't recognize. The subscriber may need to approve it or use another card.
- Card replaced or cancelled. Lost card, new bank. Same fix as an expired card.
Some payment processors can update expired card details automatically in the background, depending on the card network and your setup. Ask your subscription platform and payment provider what's switched on for you. Every decline it fixes quietly is one less email to send.
The retry schedule lives in your subscription platform
Klaviyo doesn't retry payments. Your subscription platform does. In Recharge, Loop and similar apps you can usually set how many times a failed charge is retried and how many days sit between attempts. You also choose what happens after the last one fails, for example cancelling or pausing the subscription.
Look at those settings first, because your emails have to fit around them. A typical setup is a few retries spread across one to two weeks. Spacing matters more than people think. A retry the next morning catches temporary bank blocks. A retry a few days later catches people who were short on money.
And decide what happens at the end. Pausing after the final failure, where your platform allows it, keeps the subscriber on your books and makes restarting easier than cancelling outright.
The email and SMS sequence
Trigger the flow from the failed payment event your platform sends to Klaviyo. Check the exact event name in your metrics list. Then time each message just before or right after a retry, so an updated card gets picked up quickly.
| When | Channel | Message |
|---|---|---|
| Right after the first decline | Payment didn't go through, here's the link to update your card | |
| Before the second retry | SMS (if opted in) | Short note with the update link |
| A few days later | Your next box is on hold, what's in it, update link | |
| Before the final retry | Email, plus SMS if opted in | Last attempt on this date, then the subscription pauses or ends |
| After the final failure | Subscription paused or cancelled, one link to restart |
Adjust the number of messages to your retry count. If your platform only retries twice, you don't need five emails.
SMS works well here because the message is short and practical, and a lot of people only notice it on their phone. Only send it to subscribers who opted in to SMS, and keep it to a line or two. More on that channel in our SMS marketing guide.
The update-payment link
This link decides whether the flow works. It should take the subscriber straight to the page where they change their card, logged in if your platform supports that, without a password reset in between.
Most subscription platforms offer a customer portal link or a magic login link you can drop into Klaviyo as a profile property or event variable. Test it on a real phone with a test subscription. If the link lands on a login screen and the subscriber has forgotten their password, you've lost most of them right there.
Put the link in a button near the top and again near the bottom. One clear action and nothing else competing for the click, so leave the product grid and social links out.
Tone: helpful, never accusing
Nobody likes hearing their payment failed. It feels a bit embarrassing. So don't make it sound like a collection letter.
- Say what happened in one plain sentence. "We couldn't process the payment for your next order."
- Assume it's a card issue, because it usually is.
- Show what they'd miss, like the product in the next box and the subscriber price they keep by staying.
- Give the date of the next attempt, so they know there's time.
- Skip red warning banners and all caps. Save urgency for the last email, and even there keep it factual.
Plain text or very light design tends to fit this flow. It reads like a note from the brand, which is exactly the feeling you want here. Our plain text email guide explains why.
Leave discounts out. Someone with an expired card doesn't need 15% off to update it. If you add an offer, you teach subscribers that a declined card earns a reward.
When to stop
Two exit rules, and both have to be in place before you switch the flow on.
First, the moment the payment succeeds or the card is updated, the subscriber leaves the flow. Set this up as a flow filter or a conditional split checking for a successful charge event. Getting "your payment failed" after you already fixed it makes the brand look careless.
Second, after the final retry fails and the subscription is paused or cancelled, stop the payment messages. Send one last email confirming what happened with a link to restart, then move the subscriber into your normal winback logic. The subscription cancellation flow guide covers how to treat them from there.
Things to check
- Duplicate notices. Your platform's own dunning emails and Klaviyo's both firing. Turn one off.
- Campaigns during dunning. A subscriber with a failed payment probably shouldn't get a sale campaign that day. Suppress them with a segment on the failed payment event.
- Recovery rate. Track how many failed payments end in a successful charge, and how many of those came after an email click.
- Link clicks without updates. Lots of clicks but few updated cards usually means the portal page is broken or confusing on mobile.
Failed payments are one part of a wider retention setup. The subscription churn email flow guide shows how this fits next to renewal reminders, cancel saves and winback. If you want us to build it for your brand, here's our subscription marketing service.
Questions we get a lot
What are failed payment recovery emails?
They are the emails, and often SMS, a subscriber gets when a renewal charge is declined. Their job is to get the subscriber to update their card before the subscription is cancelled. This is also called dunning.
How many times should a failed payment be retried?
Your subscription platform controls the retry schedule, and most let you set the number of retries and the days between them. A few retries spread over one to two weeks is a common setup. Line your emails up with those retry dates.
Should Klaviyo or the subscription platform send dunning emails?
Only one of them. Most subscription platforms can send their own failed payment notices. If you move them to Klaviyo for better design and SMS, switch the platform version off so subscribers don't get two messages for one decline.
When should I stop sending failed payment emails?
Stop the moment the payment succeeds or the card is updated, and stop after the last retry when the subscription is cancelled. At that point move the subscriber into a separate flow with a link to restart, not more payment reminders.