Subscriptions

Loop vs Recharge, compared from the Klaviyo side.

Both apps bill subscriptions on Shopify. The differences that matter for retention sit in the portal, the cancel flow and the data Klaviyo receives. Here is how we compare them for clients.

Loop vs Recharge is one of the most common questions we get from subscription brands on Shopify, usually right after a demo call. Both apps bill recurring orders, both connect to Klaviyo, both offer a customer portal and a cancel flow. So a feature checklist won't settle it. The useful comparison is what each app means for the emails you send, the subscribers you keep and the work it takes to switch.

Both apps ship changes often. Treat this page as a list of what to check, and confirm each point on the vendor's current pricing and feature page or in a demo. We don't cover prices. If you want the wider field, including Skio and Stay AI, read Recharge vs Loop vs Skio vs Stay AI.

The short version

Recharge is the long established option. It has been around far longer than Shopify's own subscription system, it's widely used, and a lot of agencies, freelancers and templates already assume Recharge data. It comes with its own customer notifications and SMS features, which is useful and also something to manage.

Loop is built for Shopify brands and puts a lot of weight on the customer portal and on retention flows when someone tries to cancel. It's often on the shortlist when a brand feels its current portal pushes people toward cancelling.

Neither is the right answer for everyone. What tips it is usually the portal experience your subscribers need and how much rebuilding you're willing to do in Klaviyo.

Loop vs Recharge at a glance

This table reflects how the vendors generally position themselves and what we look at for each. It's a starting point for your own checks, not a verdict.

LoopRecharge
Klaviyo integrationYesYes, long established and widely used
Generally known forShopify focus, customer portal and retention flowsOne of the oldest and most widely used subscription apps on Shopify
Customer portalA core focus, check the current portal optionsCustomizable portal, check the current options for your plan
Cancel flowRetention offers before cancellingCancellation flows with retention offers
Own notifications and SMSHas its own notifications, check SMS scopeOwn notifications and SMS features, check scope
EcosystemGrowing, check the current integration listLarge, many partners know it well
Ask the vendorExact Klaviyo metric list and profile propertiesExact Klaviyo metric list for your plan

Klaviyo integration and events

This is where we start every time, because every subscription flow depends on it. You want, at minimum, events for a new subscription, an upcoming order, a failed payment, a skip and a cancellation. On the profile, you want subscription status, next order date, the products and ideally the cancellation reason.

Both Loop and Recharge send subscription events to Klaviyo. The detail is in the names, the properties attached to each event and what lands on the profile. Those details decide whether your upcoming order reminder can show the right product and a working skip link, or only a generic "your order is coming" line.

So ask each vendor for the current list of Klaviyo metrics and properties, in writing. Better still, connect a test store, create a test subscription, skip it, fail a payment and cancel it. Then look at the profile in Klaviyo and see what arrived. Our setup guides for Loop with Klaviyo and Recharge with Klaviyo show what we build on each.

Cancel flow tools

Both apps let you show alternatives before a subscriber confirms a cancellation, like skipping, changing the frequency, swapping a product or taking a discount. The questions that matter are about control and data:

  • Can you show different offers depending on the reason someone picks?
  • Can you limit how often one subscriber gets a discount offer?
  • Does the chosen reason, and the offer accepted or declined, reach Klaviyo?
  • What reporting do you get on which offers save subscribers?

The answers differ between the apps and sometimes between plans, and both keep adding options. Walk through each cancel flow in a demo as if you were a subscriber. Then make sure your Klaviyo cancellation flow doesn't repeat an offer the subscriber just declined. We cover the Klaviyo side in our subscription cancellation flow guide.

Customer portal

Your reminder emails link into the portal. If skipping or swapping takes one tap there, the email works. If the subscriber has to remember a password first, a share of them will cancel instead.

Loop puts the portal at the center of its pitch. Recharge's portal is customizable and has been used by a huge number of stores. In practice the difference comes down to your setup: which actions you switch on, how login works from an email link, and how the portal looks on a phone. Test the login yourself from a real email on your phone, for both apps. It's the single most useful five minutes in the whole evaluation.

Also check what subscribers can change without contacting support. Every "please email us to change this" message is a reason to cancel instead.

Notifications: who sends what

Both apps can send their own customer emails. On a Recharge account in particular, the first job we do is listing which notifications are switched on in Recharge and which flows run in Klaviyo, because doubles are common. The same check applies to Loop.

Our rule of thumb: Klaviyo sends anything that sells or retains, like the upcoming order reminder, failed payment emails and win back. The app keeps the transactional messages Klaviyo doesn't replace. Whichever app you pick, make sure each notification can be switched off on its own. Our subscription email marketing guide shows the split we use.

Migration between Loop and Recharge

Brands move in both directions. The vendors handle most of the subscription and payment method migration and usually offer help with it. Ask exactly what's included and what's left for your team.

What no vendor fixes is your Klaviyo account. On the day the old app stops sending events, these go quiet without warning:

  • Every flow triggered by an old subscription metric
  • Segments built on old profile properties like subscription status
  • Filters that keep subscribers out of one time buyer flows
  • Campaign exclusions that stop subscribers from seeing first order offers

List all of these before the switch. Rebuild them on the new app's metrics, pause the old flows instead of deleting them, and test every event with a real test subscription after the move. If you run a lot of subscription flows, plan a full week for this.

Who each suits

Recharge tends to suit brands that want a long established platform with a large partner ecosystem, teams that already know it, and setups where hiring help quickly matters. If you're already on Recharge and the data and portal work for you, switching just for the sake of it rarely pays off.

Loop tends to suit Shopify brands that want the portal and retention flows to be the focus, and brands that feel their current setup makes it too easy to cancel and too hard to skip. Ask for a demo of the exact portal and cancel flow your subscribers would see.

Either way, a weak Klaviyo setup stays weak after a switch. Before you move, check whether the problem is really the app. Often the events are there and nobody ever built the flows.

Questions to ask both vendors

  • Which Klaviyo metrics and profile properties does your integration send today?
  • Does the cancellation reason reach Klaviyo, and the offer that was shown?
  • How does a subscriber log in to the portal from an email link?
  • Can each of your customer notifications be switched off separately?
  • What does your migration support cover, and what stays with us?

Get the answers in writing and test them in a store if you can. If you want someone to run the Klaviyo side of a switch, our subscription marketing service covers flow rebuilds and migration audits. And if you're weighing more than two apps, our guide to churn reduction tools shows how the app fits into the rest of the stack.

Our honest takeLoop and Recharge can both run a strong subscription program in Klaviyo. The deciding factor is usually the portal your subscribers land on from a reminder email. Test that on your own phone before anything else.

Questions we get a lot

Is Loop or Recharge better for Klaviyo?

Both have Klaviyo integrations that send subscription events. Which one is better for you depends on the exact metrics and profile properties each sends today and how well they match the flows you run. Ask both vendors for their current list and test it in a store before deciding.

Can I move from Recharge to Loop?

Yes, brands switch in both directions, and the vendors usually offer migration help for subscriptions and payment methods. On the Klaviyo side, every flow, segment and filter built on Recharge metrics has to be rebuilt on Loop metrics. Ask Loop what its migration support includes.

Do Loop and Recharge both have cancel flows?

Both offer ways to show alternatives and retention offers before a subscriber confirms a cancellation. The exact options, rules and reporting differ and change over time, so walk through each cancel flow in a demo and check the current feature pages.

Which is cheaper, Loop or Recharge?

We don't compare prices because they change and depend on your plan and volume. Check the current pricing page of each app and ask for a quote based on your order numbers.

Want to see where your extra revenue is?

Book a free 30 minute audit. We go through your Klaviyo together and show you what we would change first.

Get a free audit