Four days before a subscriber's next box ships, they get an email showing what is in it and when the charge goes through. Most brands stop there. Add one line with a matching product and an "add to this order" button, and that reminder becomes the most natural place to grow the order. Subscription upsell emails work best when they ride on moments like this instead of interrupting the subscriber with another pitch.
This guide is about raising order value with people who are already subscribed. If you are still trying to get one-time buyers onto a subscription, start with our guide to subscribe and save emails.
The moments that work for upsells
| Moment | Upsell type | Trigger |
|---|---|---|
| Between signup and first charge | Upgrade to a bigger plan or bundle | New subscription event |
| A few days before each order | Add-on to the next shipment | Upcoming order event |
| After several orders | Product discovery, new items | Number of orders or subscription age |
| Usage does not match frequency | Frequency or quantity change | Skips, reorders or customer feedback |
Which events you can use depends on what your subscription app sends to Klaviyo. Check the metrics list in your account first. Our Loop Subscriptions guide walks through that check for Loop.
Add to next order
This is the simplest upsell and usually the one we build first. The subscriber is already getting a shipment. You suggest one product that fits with it, and they add it to that shipment without placing a separate order or paying separate shipping.
Put the add-on inside the order reminder, below the box contents. Keep it to one product, two at most. Pick it based on what they subscribe to: a refill pouch for the jar, a travel size, the flavor that most people pair with theirs.
How the button works depends on your setup. Some subscription apps support a link that adds a product to the upcoming order directly. Others need the subscriber to log into the portal. Use whatever your app actually offers, and test the link with a real test subscription before you switch the flow on.
And keep the skip and reschedule links in the same email. An upsell that pushes them out of view makes the reminder feel like a sales email, and the reminder's main job is to prevent surprise charges.
Upgrades before the first charge
Someone just subscribed. They picked the smallest plan, or a single product, because it felt like the safe choice. In the days before the first charge, they are paying close attention to the brand and often open everything you send.
That makes it a good window for one upgrade email: the bigger bundle, the two-pack, the plan with a better price per unit. Show the price difference in real numbers and what they would get extra. Make it clear the current plan stays exactly as chosen if they do nothing.
One email is enough here. This is also the moment when buyer's remorse kicks in, and a string of upgrade offers can turn into a cancel before the first box ever ships.
Bundle upgrades
Bundles work when the products actually belong together. A cleanser and a moisturizer, coffee and filters, dog food and dental chews. A bundle that just bolts on an unrelated best seller feels like padding.
We pitch bundle upgrades to subscribers who have stayed through a few orders, because they have shown the base product is part of their routine. Frame it as completing that routine, with the combined price shown next to buying both items separately.
Frequency and quantity changes
A frequency change is not always an upsell in the classic sense. Sometimes the right move is to suggest a longer interval, because a subscriber who keeps skipping is close to cancelling. Sometimes it goes the other way, when someone keeps reordering one-time between shipments because they run out early.
Look at the signals you have. Repeated skips point to a longer interval or smaller quantity. Extra one-time orders on top of the subscription point to a shorter interval or a bigger pack. Send one short email with the suggested change and a link to make it in the portal.
Offering a smaller order can feel wrong on paper. But a subscriber on a slower schedule still pays every cycle. One who cancels pays nothing.
Product discovery for long-time subscribers
After many months on the same product, some subscribers get bored, even when they are happy with it. A discovery email gives them something new to try without leaving the subscription: a new flavor, a seasonal item, a product from a range they have never bought.
Build the audience by subscription age or number of orders, and exclude people who already bought the product you are featuring. Our segmentation guide covers the setup. A one-time trial added to the next box is a low-risk ask. If they like it, the next step is swapping it into the regular subscription.
Writing subscription upsell emails
- One offer per email. Three suggestions in one email usually means none of them gets clicked.
- Explain the reason. "Most people who drink the dark roast add the filters" is more convincing than "you might also like."
- Show what changes on the charge. The new total for the next order, in real numbers.
- Talk like the brand talks to customers it knows. These are existing subscribers, so skip the introductions.
Keep the balance
Subscribers stay because the subscription feels easy. If every touchpoint carries an offer, it starts to feel like a store that keeps tapping them on the shoulder. Tie most upsells to emails they already expect, like the order reminder, and keep standalone upsell sends occasional and well targeted.
Watch skip and cancel rates when you add upsells to a flow. If they move the wrong way, pull back before you push harder on order value.
Questions we get a lot
What is a subscription upsell email?
An email that offers an active subscriber something on top of what they already get: an add-on for the next order, a bigger bundle, an upgrade to a higher tier or a different product. The goal is a larger recurring order, ideally added with one click to the next shipment.
When is the best time to upsell a subscriber?
Right before a scheduled order, because the subscriber is already thinking about what is in the box. The period between signup and the first charge is a second good window, as long as the upgrade is clearly optional.
Can subscribers add products to their next order from an email?
It depends on your subscription app and how it connects to Klaviyo. Some apps support links or portal pages that add a product to the next shipment. Check what yours offers before you build the flow, and fall back to a portal link if direct add links are not available.
How often should I send upsell emails to subscribers?
Rarely enough that the subscriber does not start to feel sold to on every order. We tie most upsells to existing moments like the order reminder and keep standalone upsell emails to occasional, well-targeted sends.