Supplements

Email marketing agency for supplement brands.

A supplement customer decides on day 25 of a 30 day bottle whether they buy again, so your email has to land before that day.

Get a free audit

Supplements are one of the few categories where you can predict the next purchase almost to the day. A 60 capsule bottle at two a day runs out in 30 days. Your email program should know that date better than your customer does.

Why supplement brands need their own email approach

Most ecommerce brands fight for the first order and then hope for a second one. Supplement brands live on the second, third and tenth order. The first sale often barely covers what you paid to get the customer. Margin shows up when the same person keeps taking your product for six months, and email and SMS are where that happens.

The other thing that makes this niche different is trust. People are putting your product into their body every morning. They want to know what's in it, why the dose is what it is, and when they should expect to feel something. A lot of first time buyers quit in week two because nobody told them that magnesium or ashwagandha usually takes a while. That is an email problem, and a very fixable one.

And then there are the rules. What you can say about a supplement is limited, by EU health claims rules in Europe and by the FDA and FTC in the US. Good supplement email works within those limits and still sounds like a person wrote it.

Time your replenishment flow to the bottle

A generic "time to reorder?" email 30 days after purchase misses half your customers. Someone who bought two bottles needs that email around day 50, not day 30. In Klaviyo, build the replenishment flow per product and use the quantity ordered to set the delay. Send the first reminder about five days before the bottle runs out, and follow with an SMS two days later for people who opted in. That gives them time to order before the gap, which is where most people drop off.

Use the first 21 days to keep people taking it

Your post-purchase flow matters more than your welcome flow in this category. Day one: how to take it, with food or without, morning or night. Around day seven: what most people notice first and what is normal. Around day 14: a short check-in that asks how it's going, with a reply option. Customers who make it through the first bottle tend to stay. Customers who forget to take it for a week tend to churn quietly.

Treat subscribers and one-time buyers as two different lists

Set up segments in Klaviyo for active subscribers, paused subscribers, cancelled subscribers and one-time buyers. Each one gets a different message. Active subscribers do not need "subscribe and save 15%" in every campaign. One-time buyers who reordered twice on their own are your best subscription prospects. See our segmentation guide for how we structure this.

Build a cancellation and skip flow

Connect your subscription app to Klaviyo so a skip, a pause or a cancellation each trigger their own flow. A skip is usually about stock at home, so a simple "your next box ships on the 14th, want to move it?" works. A cancellation deserves a real question about why, and a way back in. More on this in our subscription emails guide.

Write education campaigns your regulatory team can approve

The campaigns that work best for supplement brands explain something: why you picked one form of magnesium over another, where an ingredient comes from, how a third-party test works. Keep a short list of approved claims next to every brief so the copy never drifts. Customer reviews need the same care, because a quote that makes a health claim is still a health claim when you put it in your email.

Use SMS for the reorder, email for the story

SMS is great for one job here: "your bottle runs out in about five days, reorder in one tap." It is a bad place for ingredient deep dives. Keep SMS short and functional, and keep the explaining for email. In markets where WhatsApp is the main messaging app, the same reorder message works there too. Our SMS guide covers consent and frequency.

Win back lapsed customers before they forget the habit

A supplement customer who stopped 30 days ago still remembers the routine. One who stopped six months ago has replaced it. Start your winback flow shortly after the expected reorder date passes, and lead with what changes when someone stops taking the product, framed within your approved claims. Save the discount for the second or third message.

The flows we'd build first for a supplement brand

  • Replenishment flow per product, timed to quantity ordered, with an SMS follow up
  • Post-purchase education flow for the first 21 days
  • Subscription skip, pause and cancellation flows tied to your subscription app
  • Welcome flow that explains the formula and who it's for (welcome flow guide)
  • Abandoned cart flow that answers dosage and ingredient questions (abandoned cart guide)
  • Winback flow that starts right after the expected reorder date

All of it is written, designed and built in Klaviyo by us for a fixed monthly price, in native copy for every market you sell in.

FAQ

Can you write supplement copy that stays within the claims rules?

Yes. We work from the claims you are allowed to make and keep everything else out. In the EU that means sticking to approved health claims, in the US the FDA and FTC rules apply. Your regulatory team or lawyer still signs off on anything new, and we build that review step into the process.

Do you work with subscription supplement brands?

Yes, most of the email work in this category is about subscriptions and reorders. We build flows that react to subscription events from tools like Recharge or Skio, so skips, pauses and cancellations each get their own follow up.

What does it cost?

A fixed monthly price that covers strategy, copy, design and the full Klaviyo setup. On top of that you get our guarantee: $50K to $400K more email revenue per month within 60 days, or you don't pay.

Is this a fit for a smaller supplement brand?

We work with brands doing $150K or more a month. Below that, email usually isn't the biggest lever yet, and we'll tell you that on the call.

Want to see where your extra revenue is?

Book a free 30 minute audit. We go through your Klaviyo together and show you what we would change first.

Get a free audit