Email Scales vs agency

Email Scales vs a generalist agency.

A generalist agency sells you hours across many channels, and we sell one outcome on one channel.

Get a free audit

Most agencies that run Klaviyo also run ads and the odd website project for the same client. Email gets the hours that are left over. We only do email, SMS and WhatsApp, for DTC brands doing $150K+ a month, on a fixed monthly price with a revenue guarantee attached.

Email ScalesAgency
Cost structureFixed monthly priceRetainer, often plus hourly add-ons or per-email fees
What's includedStrategy, copy, design and full Klaviyo setupDepends on the package, copy or design is sometimes billed extra
FocusEmail, SMS and WhatsApp, nothing elseEmail sits next to ads, SEO and web work
Klaviyo depthFlows, segments and setup are the whole jobDepends on who on the team gets your account
Copy in native languagesNative copy in every language your customers speakUsually written in one language and translated for other markets
Risk$50K to $400K more email revenue per month within 60 days, or you don't payYou pay the retainer whatever the results
Time to first resultsMeasured against a 60 day guaranteeUsually no fixed window
Who does strategyThe same people who write and build your emailsOften an account manager who passes briefs along
ReportingEmail revenue is the number we answer forOften opens and clicks, mixed into a multi-channel report
WhatsAppIncluded, also via our partner ChatarminRarely offered

Where a generalist agency loses email revenue

Generalist agencies have a staffing problem with email. When the ads account has a bad week, that's where the senior people go. The welcome flow that was supposed to get rebuilt this month slides to next month. And the campaign calendar turns into "two sends a week, same template as last time."

Email rewards the boring work. Splitting a flow by first order vs repeat buyer. Fixing the segment that keeps mailing people who unsubscribed from SMS. None of this looks impressive in a monthly report, so in a shop with many channels it tends to wait. If you want to see what a full flow setup looks like, our Klaviyo flows guide lists every one we build.

Paying for hours vs paying for an outcome

Most agencies price by scope. A retainer buys a set number of campaigns and maybe a flow or two, and anything beyond that is a change request. That model is fair to the agency. It just puts all the risk on you.

We price the other way round. One fixed monthly price covers strategy, copy, design and the full Klaviyo setup. And we guarantee $50K to $400K more email revenue per month within 60 days. If we miss, you don't pay. So we only take brands where we can see the upside in the audit, because a bad fit costs us money.

Languages are where it shows

If you sell in Germany or the Netherlands, your customers can tell when an email was written in English and run through a translator. The formality is off and the subject lines read like a manual. Many agencies handle other markets exactly like that, because native writers in every language are expensive to keep on staff.

We write native copy in every language your customers speak. Each market gets an email that sounds like it was written there, since it was.

When a generalist agency is the better pick

Be honest about where you are. If your brand does well under $150K a month, a generalist agency that handles your ads and a basic email setup in one contract is probably the smarter spend. You need one partner and one invoice more than you need deep Klaviyo work.

The same goes if email is a small slice of how you sell, say a brand that lives on wholesale or marketplaces with a thin direct list. Or if what you really need right now is someone to fix your ads, start there. Email can wait a quarter. And if you love your agency and they genuinely do great email, keep them.

Who Email Scales is for

DTC brands doing $150K+ a month that already have traffic and a list, and suspect email should be bringing in a lot more than it does. Usually that means flows that were set up once and never touched, and markets abroad that get translated copy. If that sounds like your account, the free 30 minute audit call will show you where the money is. You can also read what to look for in an email marketing agency before you talk to anyone, us included.

FAQ

Is a specialist email agency more expensive than a generalist agency?

Not by default. We charge a fixed monthly price that covers strategy, copy, design and the full Klaviyo setup. Generalist agencies often quote a lower base retainer and then bill copy, design or extra emails on top, so compare the total you actually pay in a normal month.

Can I keep my agency for ads and use Email Scales for email?

Yes, and plenty of brands do exactly that. Your ads agency keeps paid social and search, and we run email, SMS and WhatsApp. The two only need to share the calendar for launches and sales.

What does the Email Scales guarantee cover?

$50K to $400K more email revenue per month within 60 days. If that doesn't happen, you don't pay. It applies to DTC brands doing $150K or more a month.

How do I find out if switching makes sense for my brand?

Book the free 30 minute audit call. We look at your Klaviyo account and tell you where the revenue is leaking, whether you end up working with us or not.

Want to see where your extra revenue is?

Book a free 30 minute audit. We go through your Klaviyo together and show you what we would change first.

Get a free audit