Subscriptions

Selling subscriptions in Germany: the rules to check before you launch.

German consumer law is stricter on subscriptions than most markets an international DTC brand knows. Here is what we check with clients before the first German subscriber signs up, and what it changes in your cancel flow.

On 1 July 2022 a new paragraph in the German Civil Code made online cancel buttons mandatory for consumer contracts that renew and charge on a schedule. If you are selling subscriptions in Germany from a Shopify store in the US, the UK or anywhere else, that rule applies to you as soon as you target German consumers, together with a few others most international brands have never had to think about.

We build subscription programs for brands that sell into Germany, and these rules shape a lot of what we do in Klaviyo and in the customer portal. This guide is an overview from that work.

This is not legal adviceWe are an email and retention agency, not a law firm. The points below are what we are confident about and what we ask clients to check. Laws and court decisions change, and the details depend on your exact contract and checkout. Have a German lawyer review your setup before you launch, and again when you change it.

Why selling subscriptions in Germany needs its own checklist

German consumer law is applied seriously, and it is enforced in a way that surprises many foreign brands. Competitors and consumer associations can send formal warning letters (Abmahnungen) over missing or wrong legal elements in a shop. Those letters come with costs and a demand to sign a cease and desist declaration.

So the question is rarely whether the law applies to a small brand. If your store, prices and shipping clearly target German customers, assume it does and plan for it before your first German subscriber.

Four areas matter most for a subscription business:

  • The online cancel button
  • Minimum terms, renewals and notice periods
  • What the checkout has to show before the order
  • The right of withdrawal

Each one changes something concrete in your shop, your subscription app or your emails.

The cancel button rule (§ 312k BGB)

Since 1 July 2022, a business that lets consumers enter a paid continuing contract through a website has to let them cancel through that website too. A coffee or supplement subscription that renews and charges automatically is the typical case.

The law describes a fixed path:

  1. A cancel button. Labelled with the words "Verträge hier kündigen" or an equally clear wording. It has to be permanently available, directly reachable and easy to find.
  2. A confirmation page. The button leads to a page where the customer enters what is needed to identify them and the contract, picks the type of cancellation and the date, and says where the confirmation should go.
  3. A final button. Labelled "jetzt kündigen" or an equally clear wording. Clicking it sends the cancellation.
  4. An immediate confirmation. The business has to confirm receipt right away in text form, for example by email, with the date and time of the cancellation and when it takes effect.

If the customer does not choose a date, an ordinary cancellation counts for the earliest possible date. And if the button is missing or does not meet the requirements, the consumer may cancel at any time without notice.

A few practical points we check with clients:

  • Does the button exist outside the login? Whether a shop may require a login to reach the cancellation has been debated. The careful route is a button that works without logging in, on every page, usually in the footer.
  • Does your subscription app cover this? Recharge, Loop, Skio and other apps each handle German requirements differently, and some brands add a separate cancellation form. Look at what your app actually offers before you rely on it. Our guide to subscription apps for Germany covers this from the app side.
  • Who sends the confirmation? Often the app, sometimes a Klaviyo flow triggered by the cancellation event. Make sure exactly one confirmation goes out, fast, with all the required details.

Minimum terms, automatic renewal and notice periods

The Fair Consumer Contracts Act (Gesetz für faire Verbraucherverträge) changed the rules for consumer contracts in standard terms concluded since 1 March 2022. For regular deliveries of goods, which covers most product subscriptions, the main points are:

TopicWhat the rules say for consumer contracts
Initial minimum termUp to two years is still possible in standard terms
Notice before the initial term endsAt most one month
Automatic renewalOnly into an open ended contract, cancellable at any time with at most one month's notice

For most DTC subscribe and save programs this is less dramatic than it sounds, because they have no minimum term at all. The customer can cancel before any shipment. Where it bites is commitment plans: "subscribe for 6 months and get the starter kit free," or prepaid bundles that roll over into a new prepaid period.

If you run a plan like that, check two things with your lawyer. That the renewal does not lock the customer into another fixed period. And that the notice period in your terms is not longer than the law allows. We cover the email side of those plans in our guide to prepaid subscriptions.

Pricing and renewal terms at checkout

Germany has had the so called button solution since 2012 (§ 312j BGB). Directly before the customer places an order, the shop has to show the key information clearly, and the order button has to make the payment obligation obvious. "zahlungspflichtig bestellen" is the classic wording.

For a subscription, the information right before the order should make these points easy to see:

  • The price per delivery including VAT, plus shipping costs
  • For open ended subscriptions, the total cost per billing period
  • How often it ships and charges
  • Any minimum term, and how and when the customer can cancel

Shopify checkouts in German usually handle the button wording, but the subscription details depend on your theme and app. A line in small grey text below the product image will not do the job. Put the delivery rhythm and the cancellation terms next to the price, in the cart and at checkout.

This matters for your emails as well. Subscribe and save emails should show the same prices and terms as the checkout. If the email says "cancel anytime" and the terms say three months, you have a legal problem and a trust problem at once. We cover how to write those offers in subscribe and save emails.

The 14 day right of withdrawal

Consumers in Germany can generally withdraw from a distance contract within 14 days without giving a reason. This is separate from cancelling the subscription for the future.

For a contract for regular deliveries of goods, the withdrawal period usually starts when the customer receives the first delivery. If the withdrawal notice is missing or wrong, the period can run much longer. That is one of the most common reasons for warning letters.

Some goods can be excluded from withdrawal, for example perishable products or sealed hygiene products once the seal is broken. Whether that applies to your product is a question for your lawyer, not for a blog post.

What it means in practice: your terms, your withdrawal notice and a withdrawal form need to be in place and in German. And your support team should know the difference between a withdrawal, which reverses the contract, and a cancellation, which ends it going forward.

What this means for cancel flows and save offers

Here is the part that affects our day to day work most. Most brands outside Germany run a cancel flow inside the customer portal: a reason survey, then a save offer like a skip, a pause or a discount, then the cancel. We like those flows. Matched to the reason, they keep a lot of subscribers. Our subscription cancellation flow guide shows how we build them.

In Germany you have to keep two paths apart in your head:

  • The legal cancellation path. Button, confirmation page, final button. This path has to stay direct and easy. Adding survey screens or offers in between is risky, and we do not set it up that way for clients.
  • The regular subscription management. The logged in portal where subscribers change dates, swap products, skip or pause. Save offers are usually fine here, as long as the customer can still reach the cancellation easily.

So offers are fine. Hiding the cancel behind them is not. A German subscriber who cannot cancel easily can often cancel without notice and complain on top of it.

The good news is that Klaviyo carries a lot of the retention work in this setup. Some things that work well and stay clean:

  • Before the cancel. Renewal reminders with a clear link to skip, change the date or pause. Many people cancel because a shipment comes too early. A reminder with a skip link prevents that. See subscription renewal reminders and our guide on how to offer a pause.
  • Right after the cancel. The confirmation, sent fast, with all the required details. Keep it factual. If you want to mention reactivation, one short line is enough.
  • Weeks later. A winback when the last delivery is likely used up, with something that has actually changed. Our subscription winback guide covers timing and offers.

A pre launch checklist

Before the first German customer subscribes, we go through this list with the brand and their lawyer:

  • Cancel button on the website, clearly labelled, reachable from every page, ideally without login
  • Confirmation page and final button with the required wording
  • Immediate cancellation confirmation by email with date, time and effective date, sent once
  • Minimum terms, renewals and notice periods in line with the rules for consumer contracts
  • Price per delivery, shipping, rhythm and cancellation terms visible right before the order button
  • Terms, withdrawal notice, withdrawal form and imprint in German
  • Subscribe and save emails and SMS that match the checkout exactly
  • Save offers in the portal and in email, with the legal cancellation path kept clean

Germany is a strong subscription market once this is in place. Customers here are careful, and clear terms and an honest cancel path work in your favor when you ask for the subscription. For the program itself, start with our guides on subscription email marketing and reducing subscription churn.

Before you go liveBook an hour with a German lawyer who works with online shops and walk them through your checkout, terms and cancellation path as a customer would see them. Then cancel a test subscription yourself and check every screen and every email. If you want help with the email and retention side, see our subscription marketing service.

Questions we get a lot

Do I need a cancel button on my website to sell subscriptions in Germany?

If consumers can sign up for a paid recurring contract on your website, German law (§ 312k BGB, in force since 1 July 2022) requires an online cancellation button and a confirmation page on that website. If it is missing or does not meet the requirements, consumers may cancel at any time without notice. Have a lawyer check how this applies to your exact setup.

Can I still show a save offer when a German subscriber cancels?

Retention offers are not banned in general. But the legal cancellation path made of button, confirmation page and final button has to stay direct and easy. The careful setup keeps that path free of detours and puts save offers in the regular customer portal and in your emails. Ask your lawyer where the line sits for your flow.

Can German subscriptions renew automatically?

For contracts with consumers concluded since 1 March 2022, a fixed initial term may only extend automatically into an open ended contract that the customer can cancel at any time with at most one month's notice. Simple subscribe and save plans without a minimum term are usually cancellable anytime already.

Does the 14 day right of withdrawal apply to subscriptions?

Yes, consumers in Germany generally have 14 days to withdraw from a distance contract. For a contract for the regular delivery of goods, the period usually starts when the first delivery arrives. Some products, such as perishable goods or opened hygiene items, can be excluded. Your terms and withdrawal notice should be checked by a lawyer.

Is this article legal advice?

No. It is an overview from an email and retention agency that builds subscription programs for brands selling into Germany. Laws and court decisions change, and details depend on your contract. Have a German lawyer review your checkout, terms and cancellation setup before launch.

Want to see where your extra revenue is?

Book a free 30 minute audit. We go through your Klaviyo together and show you what we would change first.

Get a free audit