A customer pays $150 today for six monthly deliveries of your supplement. Your bank account gets $150 this week, your warehouse ships six times, and in month six you find out whether that customer wants to pay $150 again. Prepaid subscriptions are great for the first part and tricky for the last, and most of the email work happens in the weeks before that renewal.
The numbers in this guide are examples to show the mechanics, not benchmarks. The structure applies whatever your price and plan length are.
What prepaid subscriptions are
In a regular subscription the customer pays per delivery. In a prepaid plan they pay for several deliveries in one charge, and the orders ship on schedule during the prepaid period. Most subscription apps for Shopify support some form of prepaid plan, but the details differ: how renewals work, whether prepaid orders can be skipped or moved, and which events reach Klaviyo. Check your own app before you plan the flows. Our Shopify subscription app comparison is a good start.
When the prepaid period ends, there are three common setups:
- Renews as prepaid. Another full charge for the next period.
- Rolls into pay per delivery. The customer keeps getting orders but pays each time.
- Ends. The customer has to actively buy again.
Which one you choose changes the emails, and if you sell into Germany it also changes the legal side. German rules limit how contracts with a fixed term can renew automatically. Read selling subscriptions in Germany and have a lawyer check your renewal terms before you launch a prepaid plan there.
Pros and cons for cash flow and churn
| Aspect | The upside | The catch |
|---|---|---|
| Cash flow | Several months of revenue arrive in one charge, which helps fund stock and ads | You still owe the deliveries, so the cash is not all profit yet |
| Churn during the period | Few cancels, because the customer already paid | Low churn here says little about whether they will renew |
| Renewal | A customer who renews has shown real commitment | A large charge is a clear decision point, so drop off can be sharp |
| Product use | Customers stick with the routine longer, which helps products that take time to show results | Product can pile up if the schedule does not match actual use |
| Payment failures | Fewer charges means fewer chances for a card to fail | When the renewal charge fails, a lot of revenue fails with it |
Prepaid plans fit products where the customer needs a few months to see results, and where a longer commitment makes sense to them. Supplements and skincare are common examples. They fit less well for products where taste or preference changes often, like coffee flavors.
Many brands offer prepaid next to regular pay per delivery, often with a slightly better price for the prepaid option. How to think about that price difference is in our subscription pricing guide.
Offering prepaid to existing subscribers
Prepaid does not have to be a choice only at checkout. Some of the best prepaid customers are people who already subscribe pay per delivery and like the product. After a few orders they know it works for them, and a prepaid plan with a better price per delivery can make sense to them.
A simple way to test it: an email after the third or fourth subscription order, to subscribers who have not skipped or paused, offering to switch to a prepaid plan. Show the price per delivery for both options in real numbers and the total charge for the prepaid plan, and say clearly what happens at the end of the period. Keep it to one email or a short campaign, not a recurring push.
The emails during the prepaid period
Since there is no charge every month, prepaid subscribers can drift. They get boxes but hear nothing else. Then the renewal email arrives and feels like a bill out of nowhere. The emails during the period fix that.
- Welcome. Confirm what they paid for: number of deliveries, schedule, and what happens at the end of the period. Say it plainly. Our guide to subscription onboarding covers the rest of the welcome series.
- Shipping notices with context. "Delivery 3 of 6 is on its way" is more useful than a generic shipping email, and it keeps the end date in view without making a thing of it.
- Usage and results. Especially for products that work slowly. A subscriber who sees results by month four renews much more easily than one who forgot to use the product.
- Halfway point. A short check-in: is the schedule right, do they have too much at home? This is the moment to fix a wrong interval, not the week before renewal.
How to email prepaid subscribers before renewal
This is the most important flow for a prepaid program. It runs off the upcoming renewal event your subscription app sends to Klaviyo, or off a date property for the end of the prepaid period.
A structure we often use:
| Timing | Content | |
|---|---|---|
| About 2 to 3 weeks before renewal | Renewal heads up | Date, amount, what the next period includes, links to change plan, switch to pay per delivery or cancel |
| About 1 week before | What you got so far | Number of deliveries, product tips, a reason to continue that is real, like a new flavor or a renewal gift if you offer one |
| 2 to 3 days before | Final reminder | Short, factual: date, amount, how to make changes |
| Right after the charge | Renewal confirmation | What was charged, when the next delivery ships |
Adjust the timing to your terms and to what the law requires in the markets you sell to. Some places have specific rules on renewal notices. Your legal setup sets the minimum, the emails can go beyond it.
What makes these emails work: show the exact amount and date, since vague reminders just create anxiety. Make changing the plan as easy as keeping it: a customer who would leave at $150 might stay on pay per delivery, and that is much better than losing them. And never hide how to cancel. A prepaid customer who feels tricked into a second large charge asks for a refund and will not come back.
More on reminder timing and wording in our guide to subscription renewal reminders.
When the renewal charge fails
A failed $150 renewal hurts more than a failed $25 order. Make sure your failed payment recovery flow also triggers on prepaid renewals, and consider a personal plain text email for high value plans. Some customers' cards simply expired during the six months.
How to report MRR with prepaid subscriptions
Prepaid plans make your revenue charts lie if you are not careful. A month with many prepaid sign ups looks like a huge month. The next five months look weak, even if nothing changed.
The fix is to separate two numbers:
- Cash collected. What actually came in this month. Useful for cash planning.
- MRR. The monthly value of active subscriptions. For prepaid plans, spread the charge across the months it covers.
An example: a 6 month plan for $150 adds $25 to MRR in each of the six months, not $150 in month one. A 3 month plan for $80 adds about $26.67 per month for three months.
Some subscription apps and analytics tools do this automatically, others report charges as they happen. Check which one yours does before you show anyone a chart. Our guide to MRR in ecommerce goes deeper on how to calculate it, and the guide to subscription churn rate explains how to handle prepaid plans in churn numbers.
For churn, track prepaid renewal rate as its own metric: of all prepaid plans that reached their renewal date this month, how many renewed, how many switched to pay per delivery, and how many ended. Mixing it into monthly churn hides the one number that tells you if the prepaid model works.
Mistakes we see often
- Silence during the period. No emails between the welcome and the renewal charge, so the renewal feels like a surprise.
- Only one renewal option. Renew in full or leave. A cheaper pay per delivery option keeps many customers who would otherwise leave.
- Celebrating the cash month. Treating a big prepaid month as growth and then wondering why revenue drops.
- Pitching upgrades to prepaid customers right before renewal. Ask them to renew first. Upsells can come after, see subscription upsell emails.
Questions we get a lot
What is a prepaid subscription?
The customer pays for several deliveries at once, for example three or six months, and the orders ship on a schedule over that period. When the prepaid period ends, the plan either renews with a new prepaid charge, switches to pay per delivery, or ends, depending on how you set it up.
Do prepaid subscriptions reduce churn?
They delay the decision. A customer cannot cancel a delivery they already paid for in the usual way, so month to month churn looks low during the prepaid period. The real test comes at renewal, when the customer has to agree to another large charge.
When should I remind prepaid subscribers about the renewal?
Early enough that they can act without stress, and in a way that matches what your terms and local law require. We usually send a first reminder a couple of weeks before the renewal charge and a second one a few days before, with the amount, the date and links to change or cancel.
How do I count prepaid subscriptions in MRR?
Spread the prepaid amount across the months it covers. A 6 month plan paid in one charge adds one sixth of that charge to MRR each month, not the full amount in the month it was paid. Keep cash collected as a separate number.