Deliverability

The sunset flow: clean your list before inbox providers do it for you.

Every list collects people who stopped reading years ago. This is the flow we use to give them one honest last chance and then stop emailing them.

Pull up any list that is three or four years old and sort it by last click. You will find thousands of profiles who haven't clicked anything since the year they signed up. You still pay for them, and every campaign you send them tells Gmail and Outlook that your mail isn't wanted. That's the job of a sunset flow. Klaviyo lets you deal with them on purpose, instead of waiting for your open rates to tell you it's too late.

Why old, quiet profiles hurt the rest of your list

Inbox providers watch how people react to your mail. When a big share of recipients ignores your emails month after month, that counts against you. Your placement slips, first for the quiet profiles and then for the people who actually want your emails.

There is a second risk. Mailbox providers sometimes turn abandoned addresses into spam traps after a long period of inactivity. If your list holds addresses that died years ago, you can hit those traps without ever buying a list or doing anything shady. Sending to fewer, more engaged people is the simplest protection against both. Our deliverability guide covers the rest of the setup, from authentication to warming up a list.

And then there's the bill. Klaviyo prices by profile count, and suppressed profiles generally stop counting as active, so a clean list usually costs less too. Check your own plan to see how it applies.

Who counts as unengaged

This is where most sunset flows go wrong. The usual definition is "hasn't opened in 90 days", and since 2021 that definition is broken.

The Apple Mail problem

Apple Mail Privacy Protection, which arrived with iOS 15, loads emails in the background, tracking pixel included. Klaviyo records that as an open even if nobody looked at the email. A large part of most consumer lists reads mail in Apple Mail, so a lot of your "openers" may be Apple's servers. Build your sunset segment on opens and you keep emailing people who stopped reading long ago, while they look perfectly healthy in your reports.

What we use instead

We build the unengaged segment on signals a machine can't fake as easily:

  • No email click in the last 120 days
  • No Active on Site event in the last 120 days
  • No order in the last 120 days
  • On the list for more than 120 days, so new subscribers who haven't had a chance yet stay out

Opens can still play a small part. Some brands keep anyone who opened in the last 30 days out of the sunset, just to be careful on the first run. But clicks, visits and orders do the deciding. If you send daily, 90 days can be enough. If you sell something people buy once a year, stretch it to 180. The window should match how often you email and how long people take to reorder.

For how this segment sits next to your engaged tiers, see the Klaviyo segmentation guide.

Building the sunset flow in Klaviyo

We trigger the flow when someone enters the unengaged segment. Set a flow filter so it ends the moment they click an email, place an order or visit the site after entering. Anyone who shows a sign of life drops out and stays on the list.

#EmailTimingIts job
1Still want these?On entryAsk plainly and give one button to stay subscribed
2Your best reason to come backDay 3 to 4Bestsellers and what's new, plus the offer you would give a lapsed customer
3Plain text last callDay 7 to 8A short note saying this is the last email unless they click

Email 1: ask the question

Keep it short. Tell them you noticed they haven't been around and that you'd rather email fewer people who care. One button that says something like "Yes, keep me on the list". The button links to the site, so a click counts both as a click and as a site visit.

Email 2: give them something worth clicking

Some of these people simply forgot you. Show them what changed since they last looked, like a new product or the bestseller they never tried. If your margins allow it, this is also where a discount fits. Many brands use the same offer they give in the winback flow, which is fine as long as the customer hasn't just received it there.

Email 3: the last note

Plain text, from a person. Two or three sentences. "We'll stop sending you emails after today. If you want to stay, click here." People who skipped the designed emails often react to this one.

Suppressing cleanly

After the last email, wait a couple of days. Then everyone still in the flow gets a profile property, something like sunset_status = suppressed, set by an update profile action. That property feeds a segment, and from there you suppress the members in bulk.

A few rules we stick to:

  • Suppress, don't delete. Deleting throws away order history. Suppression keeps the profile and its data, and stops it from coming back through an old CSV import.
  • Leave buyers alone. Anyone with an order in the window should never be in the segment in the first place. Double check before your first bulk suppression.
  • Watch for bot clicks. Some corporate spam filters click every link to scan it. If your click rate on the sunset emails looks too good, check whether the clicks come in within seconds of delivery.
  • Treat SMS separately. Someone can ignore your emails and still read your texts. Decide on SMS engagement on its own data.

Running it on an old list for the first time

If nobody has cleaned the list in years, the first run will catch a lot of profiles. Don't push them all into the flow on the same day. A big send to a cold audience is exactly the kind of spike that hurts placement. Split them into batches over two to three weeks, starting with the most recently active. After that, the flow runs on its own and only catches a trickle each week.

What to expectYour list gets smaller and your open and click rates go up, because the denominator shrinks. The useful number to watch is revenue per campaign. It should hold or rise. If it drops, your window was too tight and you suppressed people who still buy.

Questions we get a lot

What is a sunset flow?

An automated sequence for subscribers who have stopped engaging. It sends a few last emails asking if they still want to hear from you. Anyone who clicks or buys stays, everyone else gets suppressed so you stop emailing them.

When does someone count as unengaged?

We usually draw the line at 120 days with no click, no site visit and no order, and only for people who have been on the list longer than that. The right window depends on how often you send and how long your buying cycle is.

Should I delete or suppress unengaged subscribers in Klaviyo?

Suppress them. Suppression stops all email to that profile but keeps its history, so you still see what they bought and they can't be added back by accident through an old import.

Why not use opens to decide who is engaged?

Since Apple Mail Privacy Protection, many opens are recorded by Apple loading the email, not by a person reading it. Those profiles look engaged when they are not, so we lean on clicks, site activity and orders instead.

Want to see where your extra revenue is?

Book a free 30 minute audit. We go through your Klaviyo together and show you what we would change first.

Get a free audit