Subscriptions

Skio vs Loop, two Shopify subscription apps judged from the inbox.

Skio and Loop often end up on the same shortlist when a brand leaves Recharge or outgrows Shopify Subscriptions. Here is how they compare for Klaviyo flows and keeping subscribers.

Skio vs Loop is the comparison we see most often when a brand has already decided to leave Recharge, or has outgrown Shopify's free subscription app. Both are Shopify focused, both lean hard on retention, and both connect to Klaviyo. So the choice is rarely about a missing feature. It comes down to how your subscribers like to manage their plan, and what that means for the emails and texts you send.

Both apps ship changes quickly. Use this as a checklist, then confirm every point on each vendor's current pricing and feature page or in a demo. We leave prices out. For the bigger picture with Recharge and Stay AI, read Recharge vs Loop vs Skio vs Stay AI.

The short version

Loop is generally known for its customer portal and the retention flows that kick in when someone tries to cancel. The portal is where Loop wants your subscriber to manage things.

Skio is generally known for easy portal access and for letting subscribers manage their plan by text. A lot of the interaction can happen in a text thread instead of a portal.

That difference shapes your Klaviyo work. With a portal first app, your emails mostly need to get people into the portal quickly. With a text first app, you need a clear line between the app's texts and Klaviyo's texts.

Skio vs Loop at a glance

How the vendors generally position themselves and what we check in each. A starting point for your own tests.

SkioLoop
Klaviyo integrationYesYes
Generally known forEasy portal access and subscription management by textCustomer portal and retention flows
Main place subscribers actPortal and textPortal
Portal loginA focus for Skio, check the detailsCheck the current login options
SMS for subscribersA big part of the productCheck the current SMS options
Cancel flowPortal and cancel flow optionsRetention offers before cancelling, a core focus
Ask the vendorWhich texts overlap with Klaviyo SMSExact Klaviyo metric list and profile properties

Klaviyo integration and events

Start here, because your flows depend on it. You want events for a new subscription, an upcoming order, a failed payment, a skip and a cancellation, plus profile properties like subscription status, next order date, products and the cancellation reason.

Both apps send subscription data to Klaviyo. The useful comparison is in the detail: what each event is called, which properties it carries, and whether you can build a reminder email that shows the right product with a working skip link. That's hard to judge from a sales deck.

So run the same test on both. Make a test subscription, skip it, swap a product, fail a payment, cancel. After each step, open the profile in Klaviyo and note what arrived. You'll have a clear answer within an hour. Our guides to Skio with Klaviyo and Loop with Klaviyo show the flows we build on each.

Portal experience

Every upcoming order reminder you send ends in the portal. The fewer steps between the email and the skip button, the more people skip instead of cancelling.

Loop puts a lot of effort into what happens inside the portal: which actions subscribers see and how retention options show up. Skio puts a lot of effort into getting people in without friction. Both matter. A great portal behind an annoying login loses people at the door, and an easy login into a thin portal doesn't help much either.

Test both on your phone from a real email. Count the taps to skip, to swap and to move the date. Check what happens when the link is a few days old. These small things decide whether your renewal reminder emails lead to a skip or a cancel.

SMS and who sends which text

If your subscribers live in their texts, Skio's SMS based management is a strong reason to look closely. Check Loop's current SMS options as well. Either way, you probably run Klaviyo SMS for campaigns.

The rule we use: one owner per message. Decide whether order reminders by text come from the app or Klaviyo, the same for failed payment texts, and whether marketing texts go to active subscribers at all. Make sure an opt out in one system is respected by the other. Put it in a short table and check it with a test subscription after launch. More on consent and frequency in our SMS marketing guide.

Cancel flow tools

Loop treats the cancel flow as one of its main features, with retention offers before someone confirms. Skio also offers cancel flow options. In both, check four things:

  • Can the offer depend on the reason the subscriber picks?
  • Can you cap how often one subscriber gets a discount?
  • Does the reason reach Klaviyo, along with the offer shown?
  • Which report tells you how many subscribers each offer saved?

Once that's clear, your Klaviyo cancellation flow can pick up where the app stopped, instead of repeating its offer. See our subscription cancellation flow guide for the Klaviyo side. If you sell in Germany, the legal cancel button changes what your cancel flow is allowed to look like, so read selling subscriptions in Germany too.

Failed payments

Dunning gets less attention in demos than the portal, but it's where a lot of quiet churn happens. A card expires, the renewal fails, and the subscriber never meant to leave.

Check two things in each app. First, the retry settings: how often and over how many days the app tries the charge again, and what you can change. Second, whether each failed attempt reaches Klaviyo as an event, with enough detail to send the right email at the right time. Your emails should line up with the retries, and the app's own failed payment emails should be off once Klaviyo takes over. If you lean on texts, decide whether the payment reminder by SMS comes from the app or from Klaviyo. Our failed payment recovery guide shows the full sequence.

Migration, in either direction

Many brands looking at Skio vs Loop are coming from Recharge. Both vendors offer help moving over from other apps, so ask each one what exactly is included for subscriptions, payment methods and customer communication.

Whichever you pick, the Klaviyo work is the same size. Every flow triggered by the old app's metrics, every segment on its profile properties, every filter that keeps subscribers out of one time buyer flows has to be rebuilt. Map it all before the switch date, rebuild, pause the old flows instead of deleting them, and test every event after the move.

One more thing to check if you move between a text heavy and a portal heavy app: subscribers get used to a way of managing their plan. Tell them clearly what changes, by email, before the switch.

Who each suits

Loop tends to suit brands that want the portal to be the main place subscribers manage their plan, and that want detailed retention flows at the moment of cancellation.

Skio tends to suit brands whose subscribers struggle with logging in, and brands that want text to be a main channel for skips, swaps and changes. Go in with a plan for the overlap with Klaviyo SMS.

If you can't decide, look at your own support inbox. Count how many tickets are about logging in versus finding the right option inside the portal. That usually points one way.

Questions to ask both vendors

  • Which Klaviyo metrics and profile properties do you send today?
  • How does a subscriber reach the portal from an email link?
  • Which texts can your app send, and can each be switched off?
  • Does the cancellation reason reach Klaviyo?
  • What does your migration support include?

If you'd like help with the Klaviyo side of the decision or the switch, our subscription marketing service handles flow rebuilds and migration audits. And to see where the app sits in your wider retention setup, read our guide to churn reduction tools.

Our honest takeSkio and Loop are both solid choices for a retention focused subscription brand on Shopify. Pick the one that matches how your subscribers already behave, then spend your energy on the Klaviyo flows. That's where most of the gains are.

Questions we get a lot

Is Skio or Loop better for retention?

Both put retention at the center of their pitch. Loop is generally known for its customer portal and retention flows at cancellation, Skio for easy portal access and managing a subscription by text. Which works better depends on how your subscribers like to manage their plan. Test both from a subscriber's point of view.

Do Skio and Loop both work with Klaviyo?

Yes, both have Klaviyo integrations that send subscription events. Ask each vendor for the current list of metrics and profile properties and check them in a test account, because those details decide what your flows can do.

Which app is better if my brand uses a lot of SMS?

Skio is known for SMS based subscription management, so it's often the first look for text heavy brands. Check Loop's current SMS options too. In both cases, plan which texts come from the subscription app and which from Klaviyo, so nobody gets two.

Can I switch between Skio and Loop later?

Yes, brands do switch between subscription apps. Each switch means rebuilding the Klaviyo flows, segments and filters built on the old app's metrics, so choose carefully the first time and plan the email work before any move.

Want to see where your extra revenue is?

Book a free 30 minute audit. We go through your Klaviyo together and show you what we would change first.

Get a free audit