Subscriptions

The Shopify Subscriptions app: when free is enough and when you've outgrown it.

Shopify's own subscription app gets a lot of brands started for free. At some point the questions change from billing to keeping subscribers. Here is how to tell when that point has come.

The Shopify Subscriptions app is Shopify's own, free way to sell subscriptions. For a lot of brands it's the obvious first step, with no extra vendor and a setup you can finish in an afternoon. The question we get asked is when it stops being enough. From the email and retention side, the answer usually shows up first in the cancel flow and the customer portal. A little later it shows up in Klaviyo, when you try to build subscription flows and the data isn't there.

Shopify updates the app regularly, so check the current feature list in the Shopify App Store and the Shopify help center before you decide anything based on this page. We don't cover pricing of the paid alternatives. For those, check each vendor's current pricing page.

What the Shopify Subscriptions app does

The app lets you add subscription options to products, with a delivery frequency and usually a subscribe and save discount. Customers buy through the normal Shopify checkout. Renewals come in as regular Shopify orders, which keeps fulfilment, reporting and your other apps simple.

Subscribers manage their subscriptions through their Shopify customer account. What exactly they can change there, like skipping, pausing or cancelling, depends on the current version of the app, so check it yourself as a test customer.

Because it's built by Shopify, it sits close to the rest of your store. No extra login for your team, no extra app to keep in sync. For a brand testing whether subscriptions work at all, that's a real advantage.

When the Shopify Subscriptions app is enough

In our experience the free app is a fine choice when most of these are true:

  • Subscriptions are new for you and you want to test demand first.
  • You have a small range of products with simple frequencies.
  • Your subscriber count is still small enough that you know your churn reasons from support emails.
  • Your Klaviyo setup focuses on one time buyers, with only a few subscription emails.

In that phase, the most useful work happens in the emails that get people to subscribe in the first place. Our guide to subscribe and save emails covers how to turn one time buyers into subscribers, and the subscription model guide helps you decide whether subscriptions fit your product.

Where brands outgrow it

The free app handles billing well. The gaps show up in retention, once subscribers start leaving and you want to do something about it. These are the areas where we see brands hit limits. Check the current app before assuming any of them applies to you, because Shopify keeps adding features.

1. The cancel flow

Paid subscription apps like Recharge, Loop, Skio and Stay AI put a lot of effort into the moment someone tries to cancel. They can show alternatives like skipping, changing the frequency or swapping the product, ask for a reason, and sometimes make an offer. If your current setup lets a subscriber cancel without seeing any alternative and without telling you why, you lose people you could have kept, and you lose the information about why they left.

Ask yourself: do you know the top three reasons people cancel? If not, that's a sign. Our guide on cancellation surveys explains what to ask.

2. The customer portal

Every upcoming order email you send should end with a one tap way to skip or swap. That depends on what subscribers can do in their account and how easy it is to log in from an email. Paid apps generally offer more control over what the portal shows, how it looks and which actions are available, and some focus heavily on easier login.

Look at your support inbox. If a lot of tickets are subscribers asking you to change something they should be able to change themselves, the portal is costing you time and probably subscribers.

3. The data in Klaviyo

This is the one that hits email teams hardest. Klaviyo sees renewal orders through its Shopify integration, so you can build some things on order data. But the strongest subscription flows need specific events and properties: an upcoming order event to time reminders, failed payment events for dunning, skip and cancellation events, and properties like next order date and subscription status on the profile.

The paid apps all send subscription events to Klaviyo through their integrations. With Shopify Subscriptions, check what actually arrives. Create a test subscription, then look at the profile in Klaviyo. If you can't trigger an email a few days before the next charge, you can't build a proper renewal reminder. Without failed payment events, failed payment recovery becomes guesswork.

Signs it's time to move to a paid app

None of these alone means you must switch. Two or three together usually do:

  • You want to build subscription flows in Klaviyo and the events you need aren't there.
  • Cancellations are rising and you have no way to show alternatives or collect reasons.
  • Support spends real time on changes subscribers should handle alone.
  • You want features like product swaps, bundles or prepaid plans that the free app doesn't offer in the way you need.
  • You sell in a market with specific legal rules, like Germany's cancel button, and need control over the cancel process. See selling subscriptions in Germany.

So ask one question about every gap: does it cost you subscribers? If churn is low and the team copes, staying on the free app is a perfectly good decision.

Shopify Subscriptions vs paid apps at a glance

Shopify SubscriptionsPaid apps (Recharge, Loop, Skio, Stay AI)
CostFree to install, check the current listingPaid, check each current pricing page
SetupQuick, built by ShopifyMore setup, more options
Subscriber self serviceThrough the Shopify customer account, check current actionsDedicated portal, often with more actions and design control
Cancel flowCheck the current optionsRetention offers and reasons are a core feature
Klaviyo dataOrders via Shopify, check subscription eventsSubscription events through each app's Klaviyo integration
Best forTesting subscriptions, simple catalogsBrands where retention is a main growth lever

Which paid app to move to

That depends on what pushed you to look. If the portal and cancel flow are the main issue, look closely at how each app handles those. If your subscribers struggle with logging in or live in their texts, look at apps that focus on that. We compare them in Recharge vs Loop vs Skio vs Stay AI, with head to heads on Loop vs Recharge, Skio vs Recharge and Skio vs Loop. Our overview of Shopify subscription apps covers a few more options.

In every demo, ask the vendor to show each subscription event arriving in Klaviyo: new subscription, upcoming order, failed payment, skip and cancel. That one request tells you more than the feature page.

Moving from Shopify Subscriptions without breaking your emails

Ask the new vendor how they move existing subscriptions and payment methods from Shopify Subscriptions, and what help they give. Then plan the Klaviyo side:

  • List every flow, segment and campaign filter that currently uses subscription related order data or tags.
  • Build the new subscription flows on the new app's events before the switch, and keep them in draft.
  • Tell subscribers by email what changes for them, especially how they log in and manage their plan.
  • After the switch, run a test subscription through every step and check each event in Klaviyo.

If you'd like help building the subscription flows on a new app, that's what our subscription marketing service does.

Try thisSubscribe to one of your own products with the Shopify Subscriptions app, then try to skip one order and cancel from your phone. Afterwards, open your profile in Klaviyo and write down which of those actions it knows about. That list is your answer to whether the free app is still enough.

Questions we get a lot

Is the Shopify Subscriptions app free?

Shopify lists its Subscriptions app as free to install. Payment processing fees from your Shopify plan still apply. Check the current listing in the Shopify App Store, because terms can change.

Does Shopify Subscriptions work with Klaviyo?

Renewal orders are Shopify orders, so Klaviyo sees them through its Shopify integration. How much subscription specific data reaches Klaviyo, like next order date, skips or cancellations, is a different question. Check what actually arrives on a test profile before you plan subscription flows.

When should I switch from Shopify Subscriptions to a paid app?

When the gaps start costing you subscribers or time. Typical signs are a cancel flow that can't show alternatives, Klaviyo flows you can't build because the data isn't there, and support tickets for changes subscribers can't make themselves. Compare those gaps with what a paid app offers today.

Can I move my subscribers from Shopify Subscriptions to Recharge, Loop or Skio?

Brands do move from Shopify Subscriptions to paid apps. Ask the new vendor exactly how they move existing subscriptions and payment methods and what support they offer. On the email side, plan the Klaviyo flows and segments for the new app before the switch.

Want to see where your extra revenue is?

Book a free 30 minute audit. We go through your Klaviyo together and show you what we would change first.

Get a free audit